Xiaomi Mi Mix 3: is a slider better than a notch?

Share
Embed
  • Published on Jan 29, 2019
  • The Xiaomi Mi Mix 3 is one of the first phones that uses a manual slider to reveal the front camera. We’re probably going to see this design from a few different manufacturers in 2019 - rumors are that the OnePlus 7 will have a similar sliding design, and we wouldn’t be surprised if we see other phones from Oppo, Vivo, Honor, Huawei, and more with this mechanism. You have to really ask yourself, how much do you hate the notch to prefer a design like this?
    Correction: It appears that Xiaomi isn’t actually using springs for the Mi Mix 3's sliding screen, but is instead using a set of magnets to allow the screen to slide between the two positions and stay put until you push it back. It’s a clever system, but we’re still not convinced the system will be as durable as a non-sliding device.
    Here's a link to buy the Xiaomi Mi Mix 3: fave.co/2TTSGXH
    Read more here: bit.ly/2G8MpTM
    Subscribe: goo.gl/G5RXGs
    Like The Verge on Facebook: goo.gl/2P1aGc
    Follow on Twitter: goo.gl/XTWX61
    Follow on Instagram: goo.gl/7ZeLvX
    Listen to our podcasts: www.theverge.com/podcasts
    Read More: www.theverge.com
    Community guidelines: bit.ly/2D0hlAv
    Wallpapers from The Verge: bit.ly/2xQXYJr
    Note: we sometimes place affiliate links directly to the best deals in our video descriptions, so we may earn a commission if you buy something.
    Subscribe to Verge Science on TheXvid, a new home base for our explorations into the future of science: bit.ly/2FqJZMl
  • Science & TechnologyScience & Technology

Comments • 589

  • The Verge
    The Verge  4 months ago +13

    It appears that Xiaomi isn’t actually using springs for the Mi Mix 3's sliding screen, but is instead using a set of magnets to allow the screen to slide between the two positions and stay put until you push it back. It’s a clever system, but we’re still not convinced the system will be as durable as a non-sliding device. - Dan

    • Pekka Aramis
      Pekka Aramis 17 days ago

      Its very durable and it is very good and easy thing to do just slide it! you really have to be autistic if you drop the phone while doing it😂 why you hate so much the slider and you definently have not done any research BC you think its gonna brake or something 😂 and its not awkward to use at all..

    • ivcfrdd
      ivcfrdd 2 months ago

      tangina mo dan! masyado kang maarte kang animal ka. saksak mo sa baga yang iphone mo!

    • Cyberphobe
      Cyberphobe 4 months ago +7

      It appears that The Verge are dickheads.

  • Nikz Reviews
    Nikz Reviews Month ago

    Its really simple innovation and better go for this.. or i still prefer bezels.

  • Beats 147
    Beats 147 2 months ago

    Bro it's only and I say only 550 vs 7 to 800 like the s8+ and still has as many or yet some different features that other phones dont.

  • Galaxy Koala
    Galaxy Koala 2 months ago

    Oh no he’s back

  • Ray Amatsoleman
    Ray Amatsoleman 2 months ago

    I have it
    It's a great phone
    Previous phone iPhone 8 plus

  • Joe G.P.
    Joe G.P. 3 months ago

    for me they could just get rid of the selfie camera

  • Ɲawaƒ
    Ɲawaƒ 3 months ago

    I never used my selfie camera. I need a phone with full screen with no front camera ...

  • Desolo Zantas
    Desolo Zantas 4 months ago

    I would get this phone once we make better cases for it, I mean NO ONE holds on a modern phone longer than 2 years anyways

  • Tom Xander
    Tom Xander 4 months ago

    Yes the verge as usual thinks it knows better and everyone else with a different perspective is wrong xD the best problem they could find is that it's hard to slide it down. It's not like it's going all the way. The BB was way more hard to keep in your hand when you slide it than the mi mix 3. Idk what kinda hand you have. Seems like the easier things just slip through your hands and the harder things stays in. Hmmm lol interesting.

  • Chirag Bhatt
    Chirag Bhatt 4 months ago

    So if someone videocalls n u forget about the slider....this is stupidity

  • Tarak
    Tarak 4 months ago

    I hate the notch enough...

  • CHIGOZIE ATUEGBU
    CHIGOZIE ATUEGBU 4 months ago

    I prefer this over oppo

  • William Gardiner
    William Gardiner 4 months ago

    This guy really doesn’t like this phone

  • Wandile Tembe
    Wandile Tembe 4 months ago

    Will never spend my money on a phone with a notch. 😎🇿🇦

  • adyph hachiroku
    adyph hachiroku 4 months ago

    At least xiaomi had a courage to evaluate innovation.. not like fruit company..

  • Akash Goswami
    Akash Goswami 4 months ago

    It would have been great if Apple made this

  • Fabiano Soares
    Fabiano Soares 4 months ago

    I kinda miss Joshua Topolsky work on the verge.

  • sajeevan Marikkal
    sajeevan Marikkal 4 months ago

    Sounds like the shrine from botw

  • teyzman
    teyzman 4 months ago

    This review was on point.
    Can't understand why people are calling "nitpicking" here.
    Everything he said is valid. You get a heavy phone with a small battery. And sliding the display down could make it easier for you to drop it.
    Are all those compromises really worth it to skip a "hole" or small notch??

  • Bilal Sheikh
    Bilal Sheikh 4 months ago

    I really hope OnePlus starts using sliders

  • Naresh P
    Naresh P 4 months ago +1

    Mix mix uses magnets for sliding mechanism not mechanical parts.......

  • Vardhan Shrivastava
    Vardhan Shrivastava 4 months ago +1

    There are no springs. Magnets! I mean try a little while reviewing non apple stuff!

  • JT dela Rosa
    JT dela Rosa 4 months ago +1

    Somehow, I think this video featured more of your face than the phone itself.

  • MagizLord
    MagizLord 4 months ago +2

    lousy review: having to move pinky away before sliding down? whats the big fuss? good that it isnt coming for you idiots over at NA

  • GROR13GR
    GROR13GR 4 months ago +1

    Why you dont even do a proper review of the phone

  • Kazekid
    Kazekid 4 months ago

    I still believe the best solution is a single camera with a smaller display on the back for selfies. Why have a whole separate camera just for selfies?

  • AB Aldo Payardu
    AB Aldo Payardu 4 months ago +1

    This guy hates everything.

  • Antonio Valencia
    Antonio Valencia 4 months ago

    If only we had a little more bezel so that we can squeeze in a selfie camera......

  • LEEDAQ
    LEEDAQ 4 months ago

    I wish Xiaomi use lighter material for a budget version of this, mi mix3 it’s too heavy and fragile

  • Bérenger Hueber
    Bérenger Hueber 4 months ago +1

    6t or mix 3?

  • Kevin Taylor
    Kevin Taylor 4 months ago +1

    Samsung Forever

  • tomb79
    tomb79 4 months ago

    Well I knew he would prefer the notch by looking at his watch

  • Agathorn
    Agathorn 4 months ago

    None existing audio sync

  • Mi6Pritom Gaming
    Mi6Pritom Gaming 4 months ago

    What the RAM?
    8GB RAM??

  • SALAR KHAN
    SALAR KHAN 4 months ago

    Nowadays All phones Are looks the Same!
    Let difference Companies try some new Stuff as they tried in previous Decades! like Nokia and others!
    So Don't Blame Them!
    Only these companies can try different stuff because Companies like Apple is just selling the Same Thing over the years!

  • Chris Li
    Chris Li 4 months ago +1

    Notch phones are lame

  • Thenoncrapulentfool
    Thenoncrapulentfool 4 months ago

    Oh dear I have a tiny percentage of "screen real estate" (a term I hate, only to exaggerate what is a miniscule issue, I own a Oneplus 6T) ruining my phone experience. Hmm this slider amazi...... * Drops phone and smashes it *

  • MW2mostwanted
    MW2mostwanted 4 months ago +1

    iPhone Xs max is nearly heavy as this and nobody complaining about it, I would say it looks more premium than the iPhone Xs without the price tag

  • Nick Wey
    Nick Wey 4 months ago

    Notch is rubbish when you really use the phone

  • Albert
    Albert 4 months ago +1

    You have to really ask yourself - "How bad do you like your stupid face to prefer a design with a notch "

  • Oppo Xiaomi
    Oppo Xiaomi 4 months ago

    A snappy manual slider accomplished by perfectly placed magnets (not springs) - that's engineering at works. The notch? hmm... I hate the notch as much as I hate biased, incorrect and late reviews.

  • Jaka Prasnikar
    Jaka Prasnikar 4 months ago

    I don't use front camera, the notch is stupid for me. This is perfect and I mean PERFECT way to deal with the notch for me... I'm super happy Xiaomi thought of it.
    P.S.: Slider is simple magnet so I don't think it will break down before the rest of the device.

  • feixbix
    feixbix 4 months ago

    Can't remember when I used the front camera last time so this makes sense.

  • Luis Cunha
    Luis Cunha 4 months ago

    I prefer this very much. I rather see content without obstruction than take selfies... My screen is up 99,99% of the time in relation to when narcissism, or video calls, are on. But I will be paying attention to what you said about battery: thank you.

  • Amran Ibrahim Rashidi
    Amran Ibrahim Rashidi 4 months ago

    Yes this is better innovation than notch...

  • Robin Vansal
    Robin Vansal 4 months ago

    Is it AMOLED or OLED?

  • Sohi Shirazi
    Sohi Shirazi 4 months ago

    Non of them. I think having small and narrow bezel for smartphones is much more reasonable and acceptable. like Pixel 2 XL. These are just passing trends!

  • Eran Baruch
    Eran Baruch 4 months ago

    I own this phone and use it every day, this review is detached from reality.

  • Alex Grinage
    Alex Grinage 4 months ago

    I re watched the video a few times and this review was terrible for multiple reasons. You pushed possible problems to seem worse then they are with some false information. You said terrible battery life but you said that from the specs because from Other reviews and test it gets great battery despite it's size an compares well with other phones life that have bigger batteries.
    Just gonna touch on it that it uses magnets not springs
    Most people run a case anyway so dust wouldn't be a big problem to most. Same with no water proofing most people don't get there phone submerged in water.
    You can select things when using the slide but it doesn't register the touch during or before the the sliding act.
    These are just the more important things I wanted to point out that we're just false claims

  • Eric Mazzone
    Eric Mazzone 4 months ago

    Bruh. I had all those same concerns you mentioned but I still bought this weeks ago and I'm very happy with it. Got the green version. Sexiest phone I've owned. Had an S9 before this. Don't miss it at all. ✌️

  • ዳንኤል ዲኒ
    ዳንኤል ዲኒ 4 months ago +1

    Expect The Verge to praise this very same design when a certain fruit company implements it in 2023

  • Yangtze
    Yangtze 4 months ago

    Got this phone, absolutely amazing, the slider is like a fidget spinner. AND YOU WILL NOT DROP IT WHEN YOU SLIDE IT THATS AN ABSOLUTE LIE!

  • mobileDelivery
    mobileDelivery 4 months ago

    All i heard was complaints. Who is this nobody reviewer?

  • LEEDAQ
    LEEDAQ 4 months ago

    Pixel 3 should be removed from the list lol

  • Dejan Stevanovic
    Dejan Stevanovic 4 months ago

    It's not average battery life. Did you tried a phone?

  • David M
    David M 4 months ago

    OnePlus 6T notch is actually really goodloking.

  • John Nguyen
    John Nguyen 4 months ago

    The LG v20 is the master example of what can be done with the notch. Make it a second screen / task bar for recent apps! I love being able to quickly switch between my 5 most recent apps and have notifications not pop up in the middle of the screen. will be incredibly sad when I finally have to put this phone to rest. I'm honestly not a fan of just increasing the vertical real estate space just for the sake of it.

  • William Manalang
    William Manalang 4 months ago

    1 month+ of using mi mix 3, never dropped while sliding. Seriously, are you that stupid? Also you won't be sliding it that much because there's a finger print sensor to unlock. Are you gonna take a selfy 10x a day?

  • Kevin
    Kevin 4 months ago

    Im not buying this. why cant phones just have a bezel?

  • Billy
    Billy 4 months ago

    I don`t like this guy he comes across as cocky. Love the way he is corrected by so many that watch the JRE channel .

  • Cemil PCMR
    Cemil PCMR 4 months ago

    Wait until Apple uses this in the future and calls it *innovation*

  • akshay damushte
    akshay damushte 4 months ago

    3:24 Just remove your Pinky 😂😂😂😂😂😂
    sounds Funny

  • Shamim Hossain
    Shamim Hossain 4 months ago

    Indirectly, The Verge is advertising the upcoming Samsung Galaxy S10.

  • Luigi
    Luigi 4 months ago +1

    I'm a notch hater.. I bought the MI MIX 3 🇪🇺 🇮🇹

  • Puscasu Andrei
    Puscasu Andrei 4 months ago

    if by this time you still say it's a spring operated mechanism, it says a lot about how much you at the Verge do minimal research about your topics

  • Henry Shingalili
    Henry Shingalili 4 months ago

    2:58 not a spring but magnets.. Ask Jerryrigeverything

  • Harz Ritz
    Harz Ritz 4 months ago

    Some people would not take a selfie at all..Phone without selfie camera is the future for me without the notch..haha..yeah i know it wont happen

  • Lee Grant
    Lee Grant 4 months ago

    Getting my phone in 6 days time can't wait and the best thing is the cost 4 round about £500 you can't really go wrong it will why should I also have to pay nearly up to £1,00 free mobile phone in the Stone Age when there's really no need to.

  • Harith's
    Harith's 4 months ago

    Hmm.. old slider phone can last longer until this day.. and you worried that it will break??..

  • vuvuzilla footman
    vuvuzilla footman 4 months ago

    All this effort to hide a 5mm by 5mm camera on top, yet there's a very obvious chin at the bottom. Until you're capable of eliminating the chin, don't bother with the notch.

  • Tom Hatta
    Tom Hatta 4 months ago

    Apple used to make phones that had touchID, no notches, and a headphone jack

  • Numair Mansur
    Numair Mansur 4 months ago

    Is Verge owned by apple or something ?

  • Wilson Ng
    Wilson Ng 4 months ago

    But are you afraid to drop it because you guys dropped the other Mi Mix last year? 😂

  • Tomnerb. Com
    Tomnerb. Com 4 months ago

    it is good news i will make review to my country

  • KenaDeeeh
    KenaDeeeh 4 months ago +2

    Aaah... The Verge and their negativity around Xiaomi...

  • Tayyab Hasan
    Tayyab Hasan 4 months ago

    Music at 4:15 ?

  • Techno Coke
    Techno Coke 4 months ago

    Remember, sliding phones have existed in the past. Before my first iPhone in 2008, I owned a Nokia N95, where you had to slide the phone to use the music player and the keypad. Because we're so used to the current smartphone form factor, with its big screen all dominant and no moving parts, anything else just makes no sense these days. But sliding phones are more than feasible, there were a great many before the iPhone appeared, millions of people owned them and no one questioned their sturdiness, and the sliding mechanisms lasted just fine. Why should the idea be discarded? OK, pop-up cameras, or cameras that rise up almost hydraulically, yes they are a bit questionable. But a phone that slides isn't really that crazy, C'mon, if your 30 or over you've seen it work before...

  • Michael Hernández
    Michael Hernández 4 months ago

    In the near future, people are only gonna wanna buy phones w no front facing camera bc of increasing cases of privacy infringement.

  • Yannick Sluyts
    Yannick Sluyts 4 months ago

    I find the debate of notch vs slider vs punch hole not so relevant anymore. What about better battery life? That’s useful.

  • Karam M
    Karam M 4 months ago

    oh no i have to move my pinky to reveal the camera ,what a struggle to endure 😂😂😂

  • Raunak Khanna
    Raunak Khanna 4 months ago

    This 'review' is just so misleading..

  • Pratik Khamb
    Pratik Khamb 4 months ago

    any clue, when is the launch date in india. or atleast let me know if i can go ahead with either MI A2 or POCO. looking for a 6GB/128GB variant.

  • Abraham Sequeira
    Abraham Sequeira 4 months ago

    YOU CAN BUY XIAOMIs PHONES HERE IN THE US

  • Raf Medina
    Raf Medina 4 months ago

    Function following form. It's bad design. Where am I supposed to put my thumbs when watching a TheXvid video in landscape orientation on this phone? Dieter Rams is weeping.

  • Shubham Pawar
    Shubham Pawar 4 months ago

    It's magnet doing the slide not a spring.

  • faddys1234
    faddys1234 4 months ago

    Watching this on mi mix 3 😊

  • Sawyer Seth
    Sawyer Seth 4 months ago

    I think this guy forgot that the phone literally cost half as much as an iPhone whole offering twice the innovation and the same functionality.... Smh

  • Mrigank Tiwari
    Mrigank Tiwari 4 months ago

    I don't like the notch but I don't hate it either..
    Though I don't understand the race for full screen mobile. A little bezels both up and down is fine by me. Oh and please someone make a smaller phone.

  • dark man
    dark man 4 months ago

    I literally never used my front facing camera. I wish someone would release a true bezel less phone without one. I'd buy it for sure

  • Roby Renaldi
    Roby Renaldi 4 months ago

    Dat chin thooo

  • playing with fire
    playing with fire 4 months ago

    no i like the notch cuz i can use lens on them and have cases for said lens

  • shibu puthenparambil
    shibu puthenparambil 4 months ago

    Is the screen slide down when playing subway surfers

  • Riteshya meenakanam
    Riteshya meenakanam 4 months ago

    Watch jerryrigeverything

  • mmarsbarr
    mmarsbarr 4 months ago

    Nokia N80 dual slider did it best

  • Wei Wu
    Wei Wu 4 months ago

    You are really trying hard to fault this phone aren't you? Do some research first, at least you'll learn it's a magnetic sliding mechanism so it won't break that easily. Also, please vacuum clean your lab next time. I've never seen a phone review that is this gross, with all the dust all over the phone.

  • Titu Roy
    Titu Roy 4 months ago

    far better than the notch

  • jesse950
    jesse950 4 months ago

    Where do you buy it?

  • pureholyz10
    pureholyz10 4 months ago

    For you, you're gonna stick with the iPhone (notch)

  • Magnus Fox
    Magnus Fox 4 months ago

    Slider > Notch

  • Sanchit Verma
    Sanchit Verma 4 months ago

    I dunno why but among all the reviewers at The Verge, Dan nitpicks, criticizes and whines the most about any device. I honestly don't remember any review ending on a positive note about any device. He even tore the Galaxy S9 to shreds with his complaints comprising of 80% of the video. Nilay and Dieter on the other hand provides a more rounded reviews. This review was no different than the last ones. I'd suggest not handing over the majority of the reviews to Dan, it makes the audience lose interest if all one gets to know are the flaws of a device.