Blind Peanut Butter Taste Test

  • Published on Oct 24, 2018
  • Break out the peanut butter, it's Link's dream come true! It's time to see which brand of peanut butter's the cream of the crop. GMM #1407
    Watch today's GMMore:
    Want more GMM? Watch this season from the start:
    Pick up official GMM and Mythical merch at
    Don’t miss our weekly podcast, Ear Biscuits:
    Follow Rhett & Link:
    Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:
    Good Mythical MORE:
    Rhett & Link:
    Want to send us something?
    Submit your Wheel of Mythicality intro video here:
    Intro Animation by Digital Twigs:
    Intro & Outro Music by Jeff Zeigler & Sarah Schimeneck
    Supplemental Music from Extreme Production Music:
    Mic: ‘The Mouse’ by Blue Microphones
  • EntertainmentEntertainment

Comments • 5 586

  • chloe chloe
    chloe chloe 15 hours ago

    What about a branded baked beans taste test? Or beans with different spices and stuff? Rhett would love that

  • ‘-‘
    ‘-‘ Day ago

    6:55 close your eyes and only listen to Rhett...

  • violinplayer101
    violinplayer101 Day ago

    Guess the Jif commercial was right..."Choosy moms choose Jif"

  • gaston moreno
    gaston moreno 2 days ago

    How does link take .8 times a day of pb

  • Cory Pritchard
    Cory Pritchard 2 days ago

    It all comes out of the same tube and into the same jars. The only difference is the labeling.

  • The Ripped Reaper
    The Ripped Reaper 4 days ago

    *Skippy Peanutbutter*
    It's not even a question

  • Scott Natale
    Scott Natale 6 days ago

    Reese’s peanut butter is by far the best

  • FoxTaterTot124 Tatertot

    This made me crave peanut butter.. but the thing is, that I have a peanut allergy.

  • eawrfasd sdFSD
    eawrfasd sdFSD 7 days ago

    Wew this was the nuttyest video ever

  • Vagrant Ender
    Vagrant Ender 9 days ago +1

    13:05 link realizes the underhanded comment by rhett lol

  • MyHeartKeepsMusic
    MyHeartKeepsMusic 10 days ago

    Yay JIF won! Take that my Skippy loving sister
    !😂 It would've been funny if they gave them sun butter (but it's not real peanut butter so I can see why they didn't)

  • wereid1978
    wereid1978 11 days ago

    Reese's has its own brand.

  • JadedJules
    JadedJules 11 days ago

    Jif is the best pb, hands down

  • Alexander John Babbage

    For some reason, a two pack of the smuckers peanut butter would cost me sixty dollars to order from Amazon. Also, you guys are missing out because the best peanut butter is Planters Peanut Butter.

  • mike brennan
    mike brennan 12 days ago

    It’s all about the Honey Roasted Peter Pan Peanut Butter!

  • Juri Haataja
    Juri Haataja 12 days ago

    I used to be like "The heck..?" when bought my first Reese's peanut butter cup cake, now a year later I make daily smoothie with a spoon of unsweetened peanut butter and love its mixture of sweet and salty!

  • Matt Steemson
    Matt Steemson 12 days ago

    8:18 ......that is all

  • KR4V3N9 PS3
    KR4V3N9 PS3 12 days ago

    Should have tried Kraft peanut butter from Australia, it's the best no contest

  • Nika Grdzeli
    Nika Grdzeli 13 days ago +3

    I feel like someone that eats pb a lot has a disadvantage, because they eat it every single day, so often that they get super used to it and don't think about it as they eat it, and also when they have tasted all of the brands, and they choose their favourite and eat it for so much time that they don't remember what the other ones taste like.

  • Gandalf the Grey
    Gandalf the Grey 14 days ago +6

    I grew up with Smuckers and I can confirm it is the worst peanut butter out there...I would have eaten peanut butter ten times more when I was younger if we got Jif or Peter Pan.

  • ThatOneGuy
    ThatOneGuy 16 days ago

    Looks like with the overall score, Rhett actually liked peanut butter better.

  • NIX
    NIX 16 days ago +1

    Question of the day:all peanut butter but is all peanut butter?

  • everlast19
    everlast19 16 days ago +2

    I always buy skippy . But I’m Definitely trying jiff and Peter Pan next

  • Inubry
    Inubry 17 days ago

    You lost the game

  • Agatha Clapper
    Agatha Clapper 18 days ago


  • Wire One
    Wire One 18 days ago


  • Spencer Pretli
    Spencer Pretli 18 days ago

    Kraft has the best peanut butter

  • Mainly Madeline23
    Mainly Madeline23 19 days ago


    You might not know what that is

  • Ethan McBabe TV
    Ethan McBabe TV 20 days ago +2

    Justin’s 6+4 is 13 good math on gmm

  • I'm Burstt
    I'm Burstt 20 days ago

    This video made we want peanut butter so much I paused the video and went to my kitchen and got a big spoon and just scooped a big spoonful and ate it.😂 man I love GMM

  • Rachel Otremba
    Rachel Otremba 20 days ago

    9:51 Link looked so startled 😂😂

  • Alyssa Bennett
    Alyssa Bennett 20 days ago

    I was eating peanut butter from a spoon when they said that in the episode...

  • Z G H
    Z G H 20 days ago

    peanutbutter should just be peanuts and salt- no oil, no sugar, no molasses. especially molasses.

  • Michaël X
    Michaël X 21 day ago

    I've watched a few of these blind taste tests now, and I think Link's downfall is that he over thinks his guesses too much as opposed to going with his gut.

  • caleb hope
    caleb hope 21 day ago

    How is no one talking about "enjoy it while it lasts" XD

  • maxie fuqua
    maxie fuqua 21 day ago

    Am I the only one that's never heard of "creamy" peanut butter?
    "Chunky" and "smooth" is the only things I've heard to describe peanuts butter.

  • Lily Rain
    Lily Rain 21 day ago +1

    international peanut butter taste test
    international peanut butter dishes taste test
    more peanut butter vids : )

  • TheVengfulOne256
    TheVengfulOne256 21 day ago

    Blind cola test boys!!!!

  • joshua lee
    joshua lee 23 days ago

    hmmmm im confused why they used great value over reeses smooth peanut butter? :|

  • Whilom Forge
    Whilom Forge 24 days ago

    They are legumes!!!

  • teeheegirli
    teeheegirli 25 days ago

    I don't think they mixed the Smuckers peanut butter before serving it.

  • Sollus Markis
    Sollus Markis 25 days ago +1

    Link: "Decimals are for losers."
    Link 1 minute later: "I dip a raw spoon in peanut butter .8 times a day."

  • TheLiquidChaos
    TheLiquidChaos 27 days ago

    Watching this while eating peanut butter on saltines. Brand...Jif

  • InsanityPlea100
    InsanityPlea100 27 days ago +5

    it was not your jam. it was your peanut butter.

  • Charles Rae Clark
    Charles Rae Clark 28 days ago

    Half the fun is watching them try to blindly find what they are tasting.

  • Joy Durand
    Joy Durand 29 days ago

    Decimals ARE for losers

  • Alyssia Augenstine
    Alyssia Augenstine 29 days ago

    If you come to my house and you don't like penutbutter you are not welcome

  • Jessica Darlin
    Jessica Darlin Month ago

    I could live on Peanut Butter Alone...

  • Anonymous Person
    Anonymous Person Month ago

    “I literally felt the nuts in my mouth.”

  • Matt Wiederholt
    Matt Wiederholt Month ago

    Link “decimals are for losers” then a minute later he dips a spoon .8 times a day in peanut butter😂

  • omgods1
    omgods1 Month ago

    rhet's mustache reminds me of walrus whiskers

  • Rider
    Rider Month ago


  • Tbksrk99
    Tbksrk99 Month ago

    6:30 Rhett thinks there are 6 days in a week...

  • Zack
    Zack Month ago +1

    Link I'm am with u because I looovvvvvvvvvvveeeeeeeeee peanut butter I could literally eat a ton of peanut butter for like 1 while meal soooooo good

  • killer joe
    killer joe Month ago

    " I literally taste the nuts in my mouth" rhett

  • The Iconic Critic
    The Iconic Critic Month ago

    Laura Scudder’s is very underrated as a peanut butter

  • Hannah Sculley
    Hannah Sculley Month ago

    remember when they were babies

  • Kinaibhlan
    Kinaibhlan Month ago +1

    I've only tried Skippy but this makes me want to try Jif and Peter Pan.

  • gabriella_the _rarity

    This peanut butter is great.
    -the great value peanut butter

  • Abigail Goller
    Abigail Goller Month ago

    So Reht has the spoon in his PB 80% of his day

  • Somerandomguy 04
    Somerandomguy 04 Month ago

    Rhett says 'I feel the nuts in my mouth '😂😂

  • Snazzled Justin
    Snazzled Justin Month ago +1

    How ironic that my name is Justin and I like my peanut butter both crunchy and smooth

  • jacob vance
    jacob vance Month ago

    Good math at the end

  • Doctor Potatoes
    Doctor Potatoes Month ago

    Now you have to do a beans taste test for Rhett

  • Grace Henderson
    Grace Henderson Month ago

    cries in allergy

  • Ravenlovesbingy
    Ravenlovesbingy Month ago

    at my house we freeze our peanut butter and cut off pieces and eat it like that lol

  • Ryan Bruno
    Ryan Bruno Month ago

    I dont like the “lets talk about that” can u change it

  • B Sarangi
    B Sarangi Month ago

    8:15 I present to y'all, an adult

  • B Sarangi
    B Sarangi Month ago

    8:15 I present to y'all, an adult

  • Tiffany
    Tiffany Month ago

    While this is really awesome and gave me a whole new look at peanut butter, I really think you guys should do peanut butter alternatives.
    Schools these days are peanut free and some nut free. That would be an awesome blind taste test and really cool for me since I'd rather buy what you guys vote instead of every single expensive bottle for my kid.

  • battlin
    battlin Month ago

    Crunchy the best thou

  • Mini Donutz
    Mini Donutz Month ago

    Link gets so giggly after the first one LMAO

  • Aaron
    Aaron Month ago

    Anyone ever noticed that the first one never wins

  • Idk Seems Legit
    Idk Seems Legit Month ago +1

    Man I love Skippy Peanut Butter!!

  • Wedge 0020
    Wedge 0020 Month ago

    Smuckers has peanut butter?!

  • iiRadiationii
    iiRadiationii Month ago +1

    Favorite part of the video "Let's butter them nuts"

  • The Cody Roark 15
    The Cody Roark 15 Month ago


  • CaliberTM
    CaliberTM Month ago

    No reeses peanut butter?

  • multiple smiles
    multiple smiles Month ago

    "I haven't fully converted yet."
    Please, Rhett, don't ever fully convert.

  • CurryKingWurst
    CurryKingWurst Month ago

    Funny but not very appetizing how Rhett always brushes the peanut butter off the lid with his whiskers.

    Also peanut butter is disgusting.

  • KirstenS.
    KirstenS. Month ago

    My favorite wheel intro video EVER! They are so so cute! I want to be their friends.

  • Matrix Madness
    Matrix Madness Month ago

    Somebody better make a GIF of them eating the jif peanut butter

    IAFUFFFALBMB H1 Month ago

    Make a crunchy version

  • KB C
    KB C Month ago

    i just wanna say...

    6 PLUS 4 IS NOT 13!!!!!!!!

  • Matt Katch
    Matt Katch Month ago +3

    Smucker's Natural is great! Link doesn't love PB, he just loves the sugar they put in it!

  • Sasquatch8600
    Sasquatch8600 Month ago

    No Laura Scudder's? So much better.

  • Dizzy
    Dizzy Month ago

    Rhetts beard always ends up being a casualty in these blind taste tests

  • Perla Aguilar
    Perla Aguilar Month ago

    Idk why but their game names are longer and weirder each time..

  • cierrablue
    cierrablue Month ago

    I felt the nuts in my mouth. ...That's what she said.

  • Pumpkin Patch Exotics

    Rhett "I dip a spoon in pb 3xs a week and 2 days a week I dip a square a chacolet and 1 day a week with coco chips. That's everyday of the week my friend." Anyone else catch that math?

  • Hannah Zvara
    Hannah Zvara Month ago

    My personal favorite is the honey roasted Peter Pan one

  • Justin Wong
    Justin Wong Month ago

    Hey my name is justin

  • Payton101
    Payton101 Month ago

    What exactly is a ‘raw spoon’?

  • DanielNotJeffrey White

    "If I've learned anything in math it's that decimals are for losers"
    -1 minute later:" I dip a spoon into peanut butter .8 times a day"

  • Boris Van Druff
    Boris Van Druff Month ago

    “Peter Pan was my jam as a kid.”
    False. It was your peanut butter.

  • horse girl
    horse girl Month ago

    I hate skippy

  • super Womang
    super Womang Month ago +2

    “3 times a week. And then another two times a week I take a dark chocolate bar square and dip it into the peanut butter. And then once a week I dip a spoon in and decorate the peanut butter with chocolate chips. That’s every day of the week friend.”
    3+2+1 = 6
    Nice try, Rhett 😂😂😂