Blind Peanut Butter Taste Test

  • Published on Oct 24, 2018
  • Break out the peanut butter, it's Link's dream come true! It's time to see which brand of peanut butter's the cream of the crop. GMM #1407
    Watch today's GMMore:
    Want more GMM? Watch this season from the start:
    Pick up official GMM and Mythical merch at
    Don’t miss our weekly podcast, Ear Biscuits:
    Follow Rhett & Link:
    Check Out Our Other Mythical Channels:
    Good Mythical MORE:
    Rhett & Link:
    Want to send us something?
    Submit your Wheel of Mythicality intro video here:
    Intro Animation by Digital Twigs:
    Intro & Outro Music by Jeff Zeigler & Sarah Schimeneck
    Supplemental Music from Extreme Production Music:
    Mic: ‘The Mouse’ by Blue Microphones
  • EntertainmentEntertainment

Comments • 5 492

  • Snogard
    Snogard 3 days ago

    Link: "Decibels are for losers" Also Link: "I dip a spoon in peanut butter .8 times a day."

  • lfdiaz 987
    lfdiaz 987 5 days ago +1

    Did you know that...
    Peanuts are technically BEANS, not nuts

  • Crafting The Mines
    Crafting The Mines 6 days ago

    you know what this was so wierd
    i was watching this and an peanut butter comershal came on

  • nosobeforu
    nosobeforu 8 days ago

    That moment you realize how similar they can be @ 8:26 lol

  • Rakuza Sayax
    Rakuza Sayax 10 days ago +1

    It's odd that they think Jif it's sweeter than Peterpan 😂 I think the opposite is true

    • Carrie T
      Carrie T 5 days ago +1

      Yeah I always felt like Jif was a bit salty. More of a true peanut flavor

  • Joel Banning
    Joel Banning 13 days ago

    JIF For the win!

  • RobotSays Yes
    RobotSays Yes 15 days ago

    I’m so sad, no Kraft peanut butter 😭

  • Matthew T. Lowe
    Matthew T. Lowe 16 days ago

    8:19 That’s gonna turn into a GIF.

  • TrEvOr WeNdLeR
    TrEvOr WeNdLeR 17 days ago

    Link sitting forward and Rhett sitting back makes Rhett look so little

  • Jitesh Ramakrishnan
    Jitesh Ramakrishnan 17 days ago

    12:33 6 + 4 = 13

  • Ryan Murray
    Ryan Murray 21 day ago

    I haven’t watched this yet but if they don’t pick Jif as the best they’re opinions about everything are null and void

  • Agent Zero 3432
    Agent Zero 3432 22 days ago

    Jiff coming in strong!

  • WWEera
    WWEera 24 days ago

    Did anyone realise that Link gave the same rating for justins and skippy. Only because skippy was a little oilier than expected 🤔

  • Squid Poop
    Squid Poop 25 days ago +1

    I'm eating crunchy skippy peanut butter on a spoon while watching this

  • Emrik Allen
    Emrik Allen 27 days ago

    Of course they have never tried Walmart brand smh...

    GUARD SHACK 29 days ago

    Where's Reese's?????????????

  • polite spoon
    polite spoon Month ago

    at home i have my own tub of jumbo peanut butter because i kept eating the fams peanut butter

  • SavageNarwal _
    SavageNarwal _ Month ago

    Decimals are for losers----- I dip a raw spoon in peanut butter .8 times a day. Hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

  • Mark S
    Mark S Month ago

    Crunchy People give a thumbs up. Creamy a thumbs down. Love Crunchy!!!!!

  • Ruby Harris
    Ruby Harris Month ago +3

    0:13 - 0:30 the longest 17 seconds of Link's life, lol he looked so impatient.

  • MsCripwalk
    MsCripwalk Month ago

    I only eat Selfmade Peanut butter.
    Bcs its so simple.

  • Shannon Stauffer
    Shannon Stauffer Month ago

    Everyone knows reese's peanut butter is the best.

  • Matthew Clay
    Matthew Clay Month ago +3

    Link: decimal points are for losers.
    Also link: i dip my spoon in peanut butter .8x a day

  • Rory Patchett
    Rory Patchett Month ago

    The peanut butter car got stuck on the side of the desk

  • Jshsha Sjsjs
    Jshsha Sjsjs Month ago

    “I felt the nut in my mouth”

  • Low-Top.
    Low-Top. Month ago +28

    “Decimals are for losers”
    Also Link:
    “I eat peanut butter 0.8 times a day”

  • Gormstorm
    Gormstorm Month ago

    I agree that JIF is on top but like, I hated Peter Pan brand and loved Smucker's brand growing up

  • Kimberly Quinn
    Kimberly Quinn Month ago

    The peanut butter that i buy wasn't even in the video!

  • Dave G.
    Dave G. Month ago

    “Decimals are for losers.”
    Proceeds to use decimals 3 minutes later.

  • Yoshi_my _eggos
    Yoshi_my _eggos Month ago +25

    *also Link*
    "I dip a raw spoon in peanut butter .8 times a day"

  • Pure Syclone
    Pure Syclone Month ago

    This just shows that rhett and link like peanut butter more than anything else.

  • Ebelle Loh
    Ebelle Loh Month ago

    jif was so good

  • Boatright474
    Boatright474 Month ago +3

    I was super happy link pulled through with the win at the 6th round. Like, jumping up and down excited!

  • jaime hernandez
    jaime hernandez Month ago +1

    Question! Is that couple still together tho?

  • Jetske Ypma
    Jetske Ypma Month ago

    King of the Legumes!!!

  • Terence Turcotte
    Terence Turcotte Month ago

    JIF is the best

  • James Lewis
    James Lewis Month ago +2

    I eat one heaping tablespoon of peanut butter every night. I just did. Lol

  • WeeGee WooGoo
    WeeGee WooGoo Month ago

    Litterally 40 seconds ago

  • Dillan Tatterson
    Dillan Tatterson Month ago

    Link: what a cute couple
    Rhett: so happy, enjoy it while it lasts

  • Classical Title
    Classical Title Month ago +1

    smuckers natural is supreme

  • TK Cousins Productions

    Peanut butter Is satans spread

  • Rebecka Wiatrak
    Rebecka Wiatrak Month ago

    Try carrots and honey roasted peanut butter! It’s magical!

  • Bill Averill
    Bill Averill 2 months ago

    Are these guys 31 or 13?

  • Xavier Paquin
    Xavier Paquin 2 months ago

    Of course you can't compare creamy and crunchy... which is why you should have gone all crunchy

  • Cinder Man
    Cinder Man 2 months ago

    Whaaaat? No Adam's Smooth No Stir? I am ENRAGED! Well, just a little...

  • Viktor Ptychenko
    Viktor Ptychenko 2 months ago

    Cute couple at the end, so jealous

  • Alijah
    Alijah 2 months ago

    12:35 for Justin’s they put 13 when it was actually 10

  • Alicia Bennett
    Alicia Bennett 2 months ago +1

    Too bad they don't have Kraft peanut butter in the states! It would have won for sure

  • Araceli Reyes
    Araceli Reyes 2 months ago +1

    Enjoy while what lasts ????😂😂😂

    ADHD PROCRASTONATOR 2 months ago +1

    I prefer natural peanut butter beacuse jiffy and skippy are just candy.

  • Des Makaila
    Des Makaila 2 months ago +4

    jif will always reign supreme.

    unless it’s the reduced fat version.
    just avoid the reduced fat version.

    PATRIOT USA 2 months ago

    Reese’s PB is really good too

  • Nicki Crone
    Nicki Crone 2 months ago

    Santa Cruz PB is all natural Non GMO, best is NO Sugar. To bad Santa Cruz PB wasn’t on the taste test. Greetings from Northern California 🌲🌳🌲🐲🌿 Home of the Giant Redwoods and the Ancient Ferns 🌿 🍄 🧚‍♂️ 🍄 ✌🏽 🤪 😘🤩😎 Meanwhile, EatsIng 🥄 Spoonfuls Of Glorious Fresh Peanut 🥜Butter, Tall Glass Of Milk 🥛 Watching “GMM” 👍🏼

  • Shalph Raheen
    Shalph Raheen 2 months ago

    they always guess more than one brand in a row and there’s never been more than one in a row😂

  • Alex Jung
    Alex Jung 2 months ago +1

    Link says “decimals are for losers” and then says “I dip a raw spoon 0.8 times a day”

  • Breona Warren
    Breona Warren 2 months ago

    Skippy is if you have kids, Jif if you live alone, and Peter pan if you have your life together

    • Angie Stone
      Angie Stone 2 months ago

      I have a kid, but she hates peanut butter, so it's Jif all the way for me.

  • E R
    E R 2 months ago

    I like pb but have had the same jar for 2 months now lol

  • ChickenFlame
    ChickenFlame 2 months ago

    Is it me or does link look manly

    AY CONGRATULATIONS 2 months ago

    "Enjoy it while it lasts." Lmao

  • klgonz
    klgonz 2 months ago

    Rhett: nUtS iN mY MoUTh

  • Fern and Bacon
    Fern and Bacon 2 months ago +1

    Today I learned that Peter Pan is a brand of peanut butter. Do y'all not have Kraft in the states?

  • Austin Roger
    Austin Roger 2 months ago

    No Kraft :(

  • Jotta H.
    Jotta H. 2 months ago

    "All peanut butter is good"

    I beg to differ. Here in Sweden, there's some kind of "raw food" peanut butter on the shelves, which has no additives (no salt, no oil, nothing) and it's SO BLOODY DISGUSTING!! Not even DOGS will lick it!

  • Jotta H.
    Jotta H. 2 months ago

    A thick layer of creamy peanut butter, with a thinner layer of cherry marmalade, on a slice of slightly roasted rye bread.

    My idea of a perfect snack.

  • Taylor Bain
    Taylor Bain 2 months ago


  • Samantha Peyton
    Samantha Peyton 3 months ago

    I could totally do this!!! Peanut butter is life !

  • Alex Judkins
    Alex Judkins 3 months ago

    Skippy Crunchy is the best 💕

  • Vincent crown
    Vincent crown 3 months ago

    There is an algood brand peanut butter

  • Shane Gochenouer
    Shane Gochenouer 3 months ago

    "I literally felt the nuts in my mouth." ...... GMM Gold.

  • Young Gunna
    Young Gunna 3 months ago

    I bet my dog knows the difference

  • Elle Ay
    Elle Ay 3 months ago

    Rhett: "I hope you're wrong"
    My immediate thought: Jokes on you, buddy 😂

  • mrspetznaz
    mrspetznaz 3 months ago

    Skippy is hands down the best I eat it despaired the fact that I’m mildly allergic to peanut butter

  • Austin Arnold
    Austin Arnold 3 months ago

    great value is pretty much the same as jif

  • Andy Comella
    Andy Comella 3 months ago

    I love you gus you make the show awesome and fun keep up the good fun work ...

  • Cher Bear
    Cher Bear 3 months ago +1

    I love real peanut butter and not the processed stuff... after discovering what palm oil really is it really grossed me out. I just want peanuts and salt, sugar optional... every one that has any hydrogenated oil palm oil is just disgusting

  • Lori Wolfcat
    Lori Wolfcat 3 months ago

    Link should taste all peanut butter brands now just for fun. I looooooovve Orange Soda and I tasted the majority of the Orange Soda brands and can distinguish them from each other. I hope one day, I can try every single Orange Soda in the world. 😸 I’m basically the real life Kel.

  • Bro Show
    Bro Show 3 months ago

    shave link!!

  • Rhea Biswas
    Rhea Biswas 3 months ago +1

    blind pudding taste test?

  • Leboman
    Leboman 3 months ago

    I dip a spoon into peanut butter almost daily.

  • Bitconnnect
    Bitconnnect 3 months ago


  • Heterosexuality 101
    Heterosexuality 101 3 months ago +1

    Link: decimals are for losers
    also link: I dip a raw spoon into peanut butter I say 0.8 times a day

  • Dan Maler
    Dan Maler 3 months ago

    This video came out on my birthday!

  • Ifairycat Starymoon
    Ifairycat Starymoon 3 months ago

    King Link lord of all peanut butter and lovers

  • Ifairycat Starymoon
    Ifairycat Starymoon 3 months ago

    I pretty much take a spoon full of peanut butter about everyday.🥜🥜🥜🥜😋

  • YangSing1
    YangSing1 3 months ago

    How can they be much different? They're all just grounded peanuts

  • Andrew Veenstra
    Andrew Veenstra 3 months ago

    "Peter Pan peanut butter is my jam"

  • Viktor Ptychenko
    Viktor Ptychenko 3 months ago

    "Enjoy It while It lasts" Sad but true

  • Star Lord
    Star Lord 3 months ago

    always Jiffy never Jif

  • chloe chloe
    chloe chloe 3 months ago

    What about a branded baked beans taste test? Or beans with different spices and stuff? Rhett would love that

  • ‘-‘
    ‘-‘ 4 months ago

    6:55 close your eyes and only listen to Rhett...

  • violinplayer101
    violinplayer101 4 months ago

    Guess the Jif commercial was right..."Choosy moms choose Jif"

  • gaston moreno
    gaston moreno 4 months ago

    How does link take .8 times a day of pb

  • Cory Pritchard
    Cory Pritchard 4 months ago

    It all comes out of the same tube and into the same jars. The only difference is the labeling.

  • The Ripped Reaper
    The Ripped Reaper 4 months ago

    *Skippy Peanutbutter*
    It's not even a question

  • ADE Spams LT
    ADE Spams LT 4 months ago

    7:12 with rhett!

  • Scotty Too hotty
    Scotty Too hotty 4 months ago

    Reese’s peanut butter is by far the best

  • FoxTaterTot124 Tatertot

    This made me crave peanut butter.. but the thing is, that I have a peanut allergy.

  • Statly Statly
    Statly Statly 4 months ago

    Wew this was the nuttyest video ever

  • Vagrant Ender
    Vagrant Ender 4 months ago +1

    13:05 link realizes the underhanded comment by rhett lol

  • MyHeartKeepsMusic
    MyHeartKeepsMusic 4 months ago

    Yay JIF won! Take that my Skippy loving sister
    !😂 It would've been funny if they gave them sun butter (but it's not real peanut butter so I can see why they didn't)