House Impeachment Inquiry Hearing - Vindman & Williams Testimony

  • Published on Nov 19, 2019
  • Impeachment Inquiry Hearing with Lt. Col. Vindman and Vice President Pence Aide Jennifer Williams. Hearing begins with gavel at 31:40.
    For more on the impeachment inquiry and the administration's response, visit
    For timely highlights, follow C-SPAN on Twitter cspan
    For information and to engage with others, visit and follow C-SPAN's Facebook page CSPAN/
    Follow C-SPAN on Instagram cspan
    And for daily or weekly email newsletters, connect with C-SPAN by visiting and choosing what interests you most.

Comments • 3 182

  • Dr. Eugen Wolfsegger - Dachs

    Why these long negotiations, throw him out. He is an impertinence for the United States.
    Now he steals the poor and rewards the rich.

  • Yia Moua
    Yia Moua 21 hour ago

    Woo Peter Welch! That's what I'm saying, if you want to investigate the Biden's, do it! But do it right! Use our intelligence committees or agencies. He has the power to do so...

  • For One Light
    For One Light 2 days ago

    Vindman's purple heart was for Tinnitus .. What a FAKE .. He was also caught stealing chow from Ranger School .. Porky Vindman is a GOOFUS who should not wear the U.S. Military Uniform ! ..

  • For One Light
    For One Light 2 days ago

    This is the KIND OF TRAITOR / AGENT OF THE OLD SOVIET Vindman is ..

  • Peter Miesler
    Peter Miesler 3 days ago

    Mark-Mark where are you?

  • shapolfab
    shapolfab 4 days ago

    Jim Jordan keeps repeating debunked talking points! He barely asks any relevant questions! And has nothing to dispute the actual facts! it's only ridiculous technicalities!

  • Guillermo Ronga
    Guillermo Ronga 5 days ago

    God bless America and our President for saving the nation from the traitors in the Dem Party.

  • Masteraster
    Masteraster 6 days ago

    Hypocrisy: Nunes leaning on Lt. Col. Vinman to testify on matters against advice from his counsel and the rules of the committee, then complaining about attempts to subpoena the whistleblower, and calling the impeachment process an "inquisition" ("No one expects the Spanish Inquisition!")....while members of his own party ignore subpoenas in an attempt to thwart the process that gives Numbnuts the forum to try to discredit the decent American who did show up to testify as a witness. HMOG

  • Xannon Hamish
    Xannon Hamish 7 days ago

    4:49:36 I sure as fuck do NOT!... lol

  • Betzy
    Betzy 8 days ago

    Castors questions are stupid he’s trying to get the lady to speculate that he didn’t intentionally stop Pence to fly to Ukraine but she the witness keeps saying that THE PRESIDENT DID

  • David Hines
    David Hines 9 days ago +1

    I am a victim of gang stalking, harassment and violence .. i believe because of my right wing views.. Police and FBI protects them and i was sent to a Psych ward for 72 hours for calling the cops on them.. Nothing is done about it.. i had to leave San Diego because of it and my vacation was ruined.. Even though i have hard evidence with pictures of them and their cars the police did absolutely nothing.. not once did they investigate my claims of being stalked and harassed.. I was just a visitor and it was the worst vacation i have ever experienced..

  • Kim Anh Tran
    Kim Anh Tran 11 days ago

    US. Military should to Court Martial the bitch Vindman!! President Trump is his Commander In Chief!! He has no right to get involved with Ukranian or President Trump of United States!! Treason trial for the traitors Vindman!! Shame on the Lt . Col Vindman, original from Russia he is a scared guilty dog. He needs to take off his uniform garbage Vindman!! He looks more dirty politician than a man in service!! My God, you Lt . Col Vindman in Military, but your liar needs to Court Martial traitor in a uniform.!! Is any rule of law in USA to teach & to punish these dirty politicians the lesson to the liar such like Adam Schiff??

  • Agronox DT
    Agronox DT 11 days ago +5

    Even if - and I believe it to be likely - that the life long career criminal Trump is not impeached, we can at least walk away from this knowing that Republicans have decided that siding with the criminals is favorable to accepting that we, as humans are capable of making mistakes and should learn from the experience. Vote out greed, vote out corruption. Current US Republicans have made it clear that they are okay with corruption so long as it positively affects their position, that should not even be entertained as an acceptable position.

  • Agronox DT
    Agronox DT 11 days ago

    Jesus Christ does John Ratcliffe lay on the semantic BS thick.

  • joestemick
    joestemick 12 days ago +3

    I call former ambassador john bolton! Come on, bring that stache on up the hill. ......

  • Grant Kendrick
    Grant Kendrick 13 days ago +1

    Jennifer Williams, why the long face?

  • Mike Jones
    Mike Jones 13 days ago

    The thumbnail for this video looks like an SNL skit

  • David Mueller
    David Mueller 13 days ago

    2:37:31 Frankly its much more important what my American leadership thinks......that's why I threw Trump under the bus?

  • Bronald
    Bronald 13 days ago

    fuht fuht... fuht fuht...

  • David Mueller
    David Mueller 13 days ago

    Vindman got too excited when David Holmes was brought up. What a partisan hack!

    • joestemick
      joestemick 12 days ago

      Come on. You should be thanking him! You perceive through a biased eye........

  • Adante Balke
    Adante Balke 13 days ago

    Anyone familiar with MMT here?

  • scentmachines
    scentmachines 13 days ago

    Sondland was born to a Jewish family[4][5] in Mercer Island, Washington,[6] the son of Frieda (Piepsch) and Gunther Sondland.[7][8] His mother fled Germany before the Second World War[9] to Uruguay, where after the war she reunited with his father, who had served in the French Foreign Legion

  • scentmachines
    scentmachines 13 days ago

    Marie Yovanovitch is the daughter of Mikhail Yovanovitch and Nadia (Theokritoff) Yovanovitch,[5]who fled the Soviet Union and later the Nazis.[3] She was born in Canada, moved to Connecticut at age three, and became a naturalized American citizen at age eighteen. She grew up speaking Russian.[3]

  • joji berglin
    joji berglin 13 days ago +1

    There's a disparity between the two countries a big country and a small country that has a great need to protect itself.

  • Stephanie Nicole
    Stephanie Nicole 13 days ago +3

    If Trunp was so concerned about corruption, why single out this one company and the Bidens? If there is wide spread corruption in UKRAINE in 2019, why did trump use his personal lawyer to find out info on this company and the bidens? Why not use the CIA, FBI, NSA, to determine the amount of corruption? Why was the aid ultimately released if the corruption is that bad in 2019?
    That's like giving a well known still active crack head $600 and and expecting them to go get clean...

  • bob barker
    bob barker 14 days ago

    TRUMP 2020

  • Jeremiah Lim
    Jeremiah Lim 14 days ago

    China wants to work out an initial trade agreement with the United States and has been trying to avoid a trade war, President Xi Jinping says, but is also not afraid to retaliate when necessary.
    Economists warn a prolonged trade dispute between the world's two largest economies is elevating risks to the global economy by disrupting supply chains, curtailing investment and curbing business confidence.
    Completion of a phase one deal could slide into 2020, trade experts and people close to the White House have told Reuters, with Beijing asking for more extensive tariff rollbacks and Washington countering with increased demands of its own.
    "We want to work for a 'phase one' agreement on the basis of mutual respect and equality," Xi told representatives of an international forum on Friday, according to a pool report.
    Very very big money about to HK index cfds...Keep close watch

  • darkstreak Aia
    darkstreak Aia 14 days ago +1

    Val demings said the American people trust our congressman 😂😂😂😂

  • Lonewolfthat TrailBlazer
    Lonewolfthat TrailBlazer 14 days ago +4

    If trump gets impeached, we as Americans should make it a national holiday. 🤣

    • Lonewolfthat TrailBlazer
      Lonewolfthat TrailBlazer 8 days ago

      @Masterastersoon will be independent from that piece of shit.

    • Masteraster
      Masteraster 8 days ago

      you've got a national holiday for this: independence day

    • Lonewolfthat TrailBlazer
      Lonewolfthat TrailBlazer 10 days ago

      @felix u felix, we recognize the good things hes done for this country. We simply dont want a piece of shit lying traitor to be representing us.

    • felix u
      felix u 10 days ago +1

      yeah, let's get rid of the most achieved president in US history. That would make perfect sense in a liberal mind.

    I THE PREACHER 14 days ago

    This Adam Shifty eyes keeps repeating that Trump was seeking information that would benefit his 2020 election. This Adam Schiff repeating that means there is actual evidence in Ukraine of corruption since Schiff claims it positively would benefit Trump's re-election. Schiff is saying the Biden boys are corrupt like him. Doesn't anyone see or hear that being said?

  • John Culley
    John Culley 14 days ago

    President Trump ought to immediately remove all U.S. Army personnel from the White House and its environs and replace them with Marines and Air Force members after his experience with this indiscreet motor mouth.

  • Jesus Is the Way
    Jesus Is the Way 14 days ago +1

    TRUMP is Commander in Chief over the armed forces. Trump needs to remove Vindman from the military, once this whole circus impeachment is over. Corrupt Vindman is insubordination to his Commanding Officer!

  • SRGross
    SRGross 14 days ago

    interesting we have been using our power and money to influence since the founding of the nation, every nation does this. Also find it they know so much about Trump dealings, but nothing of Biden's.

  • scentmachines
    scentmachines 14 days ago

    Vindman should go on diet he eats too much. He looks more like a bookkeeper that a soldier.

  • Sean Devine
    Sean Devine 15 days ago

    False narratives lol. The reason this whole process is happening is based on false narratives. Oh and spaghetti on the walls apparently.

  • RRRoyalty Gaming
    RRRoyalty Gaming 15 days ago

    I have a question what’s the point isn’t there gonna be a new president in January 2021? Why they tryna impeach him that’s just mad work ! Like the whole process will take like a year and there would be another president by that time. I’m so confused!

  • Harpoon_Bakery
    Harpoon_Bakery 15 days ago

    Dems making a laughing stock of these hearings,,,,omg. this is just a big joke.

  • Harpoon_Bakery
    Harpoon_Bakery 15 days ago

    ha ha

  • VooDooTrois
    VooDooTrois 15 days ago +1

    1:57:27 Nunes basically admitting that his questions are disingenuous as such.

    • VooDooTrois
      VooDooTrois 14 days ago +1

      I checked the record, which includes
      Nunes: "...none of these are trick questions. I'm just trying to get through them on the record."

  • Schultz Srg
    Schultz Srg 15 days ago +1

    Trump 2020 I’m 13

  • Matt Haslam
    Matt Haslam 15 days ago

    What is Schiff IS the whistle blower? This is like a "which way book"... if you think the Lt. Col. should have been more forthcoming in ALL his answers, turn to page 42. If the POTUS is still guilty, turn to page 37. lol. entertaining and informative at least.

  • Rudolph Reindeer
    Rudolph Reindeer 15 days ago

    Kabuki Theatre for the Deranged!

  • Teresa Kelton
    Teresa Kelton 15 days ago

    OMG bye Nunes!

  • Teresa Kelton
    Teresa Kelton 15 days ago +6

    Impeachment coming to a theatre near you soon!

  • Teresa Kelton
    Teresa Kelton 15 days ago +1

    Laughing stock Jordan!

  • Kim Patterson
    Kim Patterson 15 days ago

    I wish the REPUBIKKKANS get on with the
    ?ing about the P"RACIST"DENT and stop with the shananigans trying 2 implement OBAMA and the BIDENS! This is not about THEM! Stop diverting attention off of the CRIMINAL AT HAND! They question why the Dems won't allow Biden 2 testify, well... Why won't the P"RACIST"DENT testify and why did he tell the witnesses subpoenaed not 2 show up? Talk about the pot calling the kettle black! I YIELD!!!

    • Nathan Johnson
      Nathan Johnson 7 days ago

      Bush & Obama were both terrible presidents, no matter how you slice it. Founding Fathers would have shot them both. Have yourself a lovely day there.

    • Nathan Johnson
      Nathan Johnson 7 days ago

      Very likely just some low intelligence black identity extremist. I live in the biggest, black hood and love ebony mommas by the way but some of ya'll broads got some serious issues and are the most racist morons there is while barking about it at the same time.

    • Nathan Johnson
      Nathan Johnson 7 days ago

      Yes, one... because both of your kind are a serious problem and destroying this country.

    • Nathan Johnson
      Nathan Johnson 7 days ago

      The funny part is I never personally attacked you or your character and only said it goes a little beyond one party politics. Chill the fuck out you spaz. I will repost my earlier comment but wanted to proof read it and then post again because it was on the fly and a sensitive issue. You Obama worshipers are just as bad as Trumps. Two peas in a pod.

    • Nathan Johnson
      Nathan Johnson 7 days ago

      Go smoke a joint or drink a beer, pop a xan or something. You clearly need some.

  • Thomas Stuart
    Thomas Stuart 15 days ago

    My first thought is that someone caught these two leaking, because they are both coordinators that move sensitive data between departments and they may have been offered this as their way out. Or not, who knows.

  • Thompson Vac
    Thompson Vac 15 days ago +1

    damn lefties wont read the transcript

    • Slamz Dunk
      Slamz Dunk 15 days ago +2

      do you mean the transcript that says "this is not a transcript"? 😂😭

  • Joel Lee
    Joel Lee 15 days ago +3

    4:33:48 - I know for a FACT! that Jim Jordan talks a lot...
    Please ask good questions, and if you can't find any good questions to ask, give your time to someone who will.
    Thank you.

  • the raid was boring so now i have to do it myself


  • Erma Whipple
    Erma Whipple 15 days ago

    mr. vindman is a traitor, guilty of TREASON! Wearing his uniform while LYING TO CONGRESS is a DISGRACE to the military and a slap in the face to every serviceman/woman that has ever served the USA and the Commander in Chief. He deserves a COURT-MARTIAL and must be tried for TREASON.
    Seeing that uniform on him is DISGUSTING!
    mr. vindman is a TRAITOR!

    • Erma Whipple
      Erma Whipple 10 days ago

      On to the Senate and RULE OF LAW! Sleazy, slimy, leaking, liar, pedo Schiffty should be shaking in his shoes. 🍿🍿🍿

    • Slamz Dunk
      Slamz Dunk 15 days ago

      shut up boomer

  • Tom Campbell
    Tom Campbell 15 days ago +1

    CONGRESS hits a NEW LOW with a CLOWN SHOW starring Adam Schiff... very sad....

  • diva d
    diva d 15 days ago

    Retard Nation

  • Avy Andre
    Avy Andre 15 days ago

    Waste of TV time I rather be watching reruns from the f****** 1800 or some crap been watching the dumbass b**** about something that I give a rat's ass about. How about we get new Congress people cuz he's people been doing this job for way too f****** long and the fact that they get money until the day they die that's an issue to me that needs to be addressed we should start bitching about that why is Congress people making so much money why are these pedophile alcoholics jailbait running our country you're worrying about the president but yet we got these people running our country until they die that's not fair

  • David Howard
    David Howard 15 days ago

    Lt. Col. Struggled to read his own opening statement...

  • CeeStyleDj
    CeeStyleDj 15 days ago

    It's essentially 10 to 2 in the likes to dislikes Ratio. Or if you want to be specific 9.9 to 2.2. it's time for conservatives and Republicans to get on the right side of History. Literally the vast majority of Americans are dissatisfied with this Administration and Trump being president.

  • Dan The man
    Dan The man 15 days ago +1

    Potato!!! Lol

  • SouthWest Grandpa 62
    SouthWest Grandpa 62 15 days ago


  • Shauna McLean
    Shauna McLean 15 days ago

    So hear me out.. I honestly believe trump is a stupid narcissistic ass. I believe he honestly believes he did nothing criminal bc he’s just that stupid but also bc he had Sondland and Gils in his ear pushing this shit saying “it’s ok”. Do I think that makes him non-responsible, fuck no, if your that stupid you deserve to be impeached, frankily fucking hung. But I’m that same breath Sond and Gils should be hanging right beside him, they are as nastily corrupt as trump is and more than likely we’re just as manipulative. I also believe that the investigation in Biden and his son should be next bc I’m tired of all this back water shit in our government. Time to clean them All our. R or D, it’s time to clean the house.

  • The Death Twitch
    The Death Twitch 15 days ago