Mixing Every Beauty Guru's Eyeshadow Palette Together

  • Published on Oct 31, 2018
  • Yes, we did this. So I have done a few bad makeup science experiments before with my own nude lipsticks, foundations, eyeshadows, liquid lipsticks, and highlighters, and I've also mixed together every lipstick from Sephora, but I wanted to think more dramatic this time, so I bought every online beauty guru's eyeshadow palette that was currently available, and we mixed them together into one Frankenguru eyeshadow. What do you think it should be named?
    Check out our merch here: fiendsbysaf.com/
    If your size is sold out, we're restocking ASAP so sign up for email updates!
    Game of Thrones Theme - Western Cover
    via BenDanProductions
    Kevin MacLeod - Sneaky Snitch
    Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported- CC BY 3.0
    Disclaimer: We only bought and mixed palettes that I could buy firsthand (still available from a credible retailer), so palettes that were released essentially from mid-2017 onwards. We also focused on gurus who post content primarily in English, just to keep it the experiment to one market.
    Aspyn Ovard x tarte
    Carmi x Makeup Revolution - Kiss Of Fire
    Carli Bybel x BH Cosmetics
    Chloe Morello x Ciate London - pretty, fun and fearless
    Chloe Morello x Pixi - Romantic Radiance
    Desi + Katy x Dose of Colors - Friendcation
    Dominique Cosmetics - Latte
    Dominique Cosmetics - Lemonade
    Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Needs
    Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Wants
    Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - It's All Wild
    Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - Vacation Mode
    Huda Beauty - Amethyst Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Coral Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Desert Dusk
    Huda Beauty - Electric Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Emerald Obsessios
    Huda Beauty - Gemstone Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Mauve Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Warm Brown Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Rose Gold Remastered
    Huda Beauty - Ruby Obessions
    Huda Beauty - Sapphire Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Smokey Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Topaz Obsessions
    iluvsarahii x Colourpop - $aucey
    iluvsarahii x Dose of Colors
    Imogenation x Makeup Revolution
    ItsJudyTime x Pixi - ItsEyeTime
    ItsMyRayeRaye x BH Cosmetics
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - The Jaclyn Hill Palette
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Armed & Gorgeous
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Bling Boss
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Dark Magic
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Ring The Alarm
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Androgyny
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Beauty Killer
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Blood Sugar
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Thirsty
    Kandee Johnson x Too Faced - I Want Kandee
    Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - Dream St
    Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - The Zodiac
    Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Daydream
    Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Kaleidoscope Dream
    Laura Lee Los Angeles - Boss Babe
    Laura Lee Los Angeles - Cat's Pajamas
    Laura Lee Los Angeles - Nudie Patootie
    Laura Lee Los Angeles - Party Animal
    Makeup Geek - Always
    Makeup Geek - Forever
    Makeup Geek - I’m So Extra
    Makeup Geek - In The Nude
    Makeup Geek - Not So Basic
    Manny MUA Lunar Beauty - Life's A Drag
    Marzia x Winky Lux - Natura
    Marzia x Winky Lux - La Frutta
    Melissa Michelle x ULTA Beauty - Bring On The Glam
    Nicol Concilio x Violet Voss
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Goal Getter
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Heat Stroke
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Play With Me
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Stay With Me
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Sugah Mama
    Shaaanxo x BH Cosmetics - The Remix
    Shayla x Colourpop - Perception
    Shayla x Maybelline - The City Mini
    Soph x Makeup Revolution
    Soph x Makeup Revolution - Extra Spice
    Tammi x Makeup Revolution - Tropical Paradise
    Tanya Burr Cosmetics - Jingle & Mingle Night Palette
    Stacey Marie MUA x BPerfect Cosmetics
    Karrueche x Colourpop - She "Fem Rosa"
    BelleJorden x Makeup Revolution - Obsession Palette
    Some people say Norvina of ABH was once a Beauty TheXvidr, and she has a bunch of palettes.
    Karrueche x Colourpop - Brown Sugar
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Alien Palette
    Huda Beauty - New Nudes
    Amber Scholl - 24K Gold Eyeshadow Palette
    James Charles x Morphe - Unleash Your Inner Artist Palette
    Christen Dominique - Dominique Cosmetics Berries & Cream Palette
    But based on the color breakdowns of those palettes, I do not think that their presence would have drastically altered the final #Frankenguru color!
    This video is NOT sponsored!
    Safiya's Instagram: instagram.com/safiyany/
    Twitter: twitter.com/safiyajn
    Facebook: facebook.com/safnygaard/
    Assistant Editors: Emily Linden & Claire Wiley

Comments • 29 289

  • Safiya Nygaard
    Safiya Nygaard  3 months ago +18698

    HELLO FRIENDS!! yes, we did this. please look to the description for a list of palettes mixed and a running list of upcoming palettes that were not included! love u guys!! xoxo, saf

    • Chloe Hackworth
      Chloe Hackworth 23 days ago

      Hi I’m the 500th reply

    • Pia Monsen
      Pia Monsen 26 days ago

      Safiya Nygaard im nr 500 comment!!!!!

    • Hannah Mannlein
      Hannah Mannlein Month ago

      You should do a full face of “free” makeup from Wish

    • bru.itsPaige
      bru.itsPaige Month ago

      You should mix every Jeffrey Stars lipsticks 💄 x

    OOF SQUAD Day ago

    what are you going to do with all of the pallets

  • Halyn Roberts
    Halyn Roberts Day ago

    you should mix every perfume from a drugstore

  • Vienne Animates
    Vienne Animates Day ago

    It's so satisfying when you scraped off the eye shadow but I wouldn't do it myself because it hurts

  • Sahil Waziri
    Sahil Waziri Day ago

    You missed

  • Daisy Chapman
    Daisy Chapman Day ago

    Weres James Charles

  • Ivana Todorova
    Ivana Todorova Day ago +1

    Just letting you know you forgot James Charles pallet

  • Slime Gamer Vloger

    How dare you forget a James Charles pallet 😭😭
    Ps that was just a joke 😂😂😂

  • Guđný Rún
    Guđný Rún Day ago

    It a just a matter of time before she posts a video called: " Mixing All My Mixed Eyeshadows Together"

  • maya molev
    maya molev Day ago

    hey, what about david star 😄😄 - love from Israel

  • Noelani Hendrickson

    Still waiting on that - living like an eyeshadow palette for a day

  • Zoey_ Kelley
    Zoey_ Kelley Day ago

    Franken Guru is a really pretty color on you, Saf! I actually really like it.

  • Its Thomas
    Its Thomas Day ago

    Why no James Charles

  • GalaxyGirl
    GalaxyGirl Day ago


  • Lilli Marcengill
    Lilli Marcengill Day ago +1

    Hey you should make merch that doesn’t have swearing on it, it’s not that I care about swearing but I’m still in school, and so are a percentage of your other viewers. Idk just an idea! Love ya! ❤️

  • G And G L
    G And G L Day ago +1


  • Senia Ziegler
    Senia Ziegler Day ago

    Who is just looking for haters

  • It's a Jewelia Thing

    that's a lot of makeup sis you tryna pass?????😂😂😂😂

  • Sophia Flores
    Sophia Flores Day ago

    the name should be : Death Rise

  • Niamh Robinson
    Niamh Robinson Day ago

    Are you Jewish cause I saw it said Yom Kippur on your calendar and I just learnt about that in religious studies the others day Xxx???

  • mary mcrae
    mary mcrae Day ago

    melt wish make up

  • Jenaye Moffatt
    Jenaye Moffatt Day ago

    I'm not one of the "beautiful people" (beauty guru fan) so can anyone give me the sh!t on what's been going on recently? It'll probably give me another reason to avoid the community 😂

  • Kawaii DemonCactus

    ;-; why no james charles palettes? ;-;

  • Shobana R
    Shobana R Day ago

    Heyyy i have a suggestion! Next tinme when you mix eyeshadows, you can mix mattes in one cup, and shimmer/glitters in another cup. Just a suggestion so that the makeup will look better and blend better haha

  • Abbie Mundell
    Abbie Mundell 2 days ago

    I wished you did the James Charles pallet. But I still enjoyed the video.

  • Illusionen
    Illusionen 2 days ago

    I love the fact that you don’t just mix everything!

  • John Brimeyer
    John Brimeyer 2 days ago

    What about James

  • TheRobloxCharmander 76510


    Is that H💿L💿?

  • fiene kester
    fiene kester 2 days ago +1

    Make a franken-blush!

  • Elle Mullins
    Elle Mullins 2 days ago

    You should name it rose gold

  • Malini Bridgemohan
    Malini Bridgemohan 2 days ago +1

    Anyone else in 2019

  • Maryann Passanisi
    Maryann Passanisi 2 days ago

    You forgot the James Charles Palette but it’s fine it doesn’t bother me at all I just thought I would tell you

  • Summer Britton
    Summer Britton 2 days ago


  • paranoid android
    paranoid android 2 days ago +1

    Babe how much did this cost?? A great sacrifice in the name of science

  • Pugnut life
    Pugnut life 2 days ago


  • Galactic Dreamer
    Galactic Dreamer 2 days ago

    How is Kylie Cosmetics Palette not here?

  • Alex G
    Alex G 2 days ago +1

    Please actually make and sell a palette called Theoretical. 😂

  • Mia Sophia
    Mia Sophia 2 days ago +2

    woww Imagine how much work/effort, money, and time she puts into her videos.. y’all should appreciate how much she puts into her videos because it’s incredible and amazing!!!! She deserves the world!! LOVE YOUU SAFIYA❤️❤️

  • Claudette Hidayathullah

    They're Marvel eyeshadows now!
    This killed me. I was watching it at night.

  • Emily Duhamel
    Emily Duhamel 2 days ago

    You die in the end

  • Make the world Glossier

    I really want you to make an eyeshadow pallet now!!💕🌸

  • Astrid Neill
    Astrid Neill 2 days ago

    She posted this right before James Charles released his palette. :P

    Akari GACHA STUDIO 2 days ago

    Safiya : And the third part will be living as a pallet for a day.
    Me:OMG YES BEST IDEA 😂🤣🤣😂🙂

  • Olivia Davis
    Olivia Davis 2 days ago

    Ohhh I thought James Charles was on here so I clicked

  • Bella Stewart
    Bella Stewart 2 days ago

    You should make a Franken line

  • Maggie Imogen
    Maggie Imogen 2 days ago +1

    James Charles is shaking.

  • TripleA
    TripleA 2 days ago

    Let’s all pray

    For Safiya’s wallet

  • bubble princess19
    bubble princess19 2 days ago

    *jAmEs ChArLeS wAs LaTe* *NoOoOoOoOoOo*

  • Lo Fernandes
    Lo Fernandes 2 days ago

    I do believe Jeffree's make up is king's landing

  • Ella Martino
    Ella Martino 2 days ago

    you did not do James Charles

  • Zia Zatarra
    Zia Zatarra 2 days ago

    The direction of which the toilet water flushes and that it changes in the different in each hemisphere , is just a myth.

  • Insert Witty Username


    I'm so sorry, my dirty mind has taken over.

  • TaeSipsTea 7
    TaeSipsTea 7 2 days ago

    13:24 there could be 2 nude shades called diet coke and root beer

  • pretty kitty
    pretty kitty 2 days ago

    Now you have a lot of makeup palettes

  • Caroline crawford
    Caroline crawford 2 days ago

    What about James everybody knows James chales

  • crafts,creation,andreviews

    9:53 she became patrickstarr

  • ᴀᴇsᴛʜᴇᴛɪᴄ_ sᴏᴜɴᴅᴢ

    What about James Charles palette?

    • Maggie Imogen
      Maggie Imogen 2 days ago +1

      ᴀᴇsᴛʜᴇᴛɪᴄ_ sᴏᴜɴᴅᴢ it wasn’t out when saf filmed this

  • Roselyn 999
    Roselyn 999 2 days ago

    11:57 😂lol
    Also 12:07

  • Madison Bartkiewicz
    Madison Bartkiewicz 2 days ago

    I'm surprised james Charles wasn't in there

    • Nabiha Zulfqar
      Nabiha Zulfqar 2 days ago

      Madison Bartkiewicz it didn’t come out at the time she filmed this

  • Skylar & Pepper Animations!



  • Lauren Papile
    Lauren Papile 2 days ago

    I am dumb Illinois also

  • Pru Meow
    Pru Meow 2 days ago

    In the ASMR nun-plague thing, you do die. The last couple minutes are essentially her shaking some beads at a dead body, infected with the bubonic plague, and is kind of a time traveler

  • Margaux Dempsey ,
    Margaux Dempsey , 3 days ago

    Next video: full face of Frankenstein makeup

  • Kassidy Berry
    Kassidy Berry 3 days ago

    What about James Charles

  • Brenna's Blessed
    Brenna's Blessed 3 days ago

    no james charels!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • Naomi Erling
    Naomi Erling 3 days ago

    Who else is sad that she didn't get the James Charles eye shadow palette

    Josie OLEJNICZAK 3 days ago

    Who else needs some safty babies

  • Elisabeth Rajand
    Elisabeth Rajand 3 days ago

    For me only this works well *ZEPISGUIDES. COM* Added unlimited resources to my account already.

  • Elisabeth Rajand
    Elisabeth Rajand 3 days ago

    Try this one...it's what I always use to get tons of coins and trilithium *ZEPISGUIDES. COM*

  • Elisabeth Rajand
    Elisabeth Rajand 3 days ago

    If you would like add full of resources Try this one, works best for me! *zepisguides. com*

  • Elisabeth Rajand
    Elisabeth Rajand 3 days ago

    Try this...it's what I always use to get full of resources *zepisguides. com*

  • Via Franks
    Via Franks 3 days ago

    I'm from Illinois too #illinoissquad

  • Ame Blue
    Ame Blue 3 days ago

    Because of Tyler I can't say Huda Beauty now

  • LA Lifestyle
    LA Lifestyle 3 days ago +1

    Can you Live like an eyeshadow pallete? I would 🖤 That!

  • The 5 Fam
    The 5 Fam 3 days ago

    I think you should name it suger daddy

  • Audrey Peralta
    Audrey Peralta 3 days ago

    holy shit imagine how much all of this would cost ahhh

  • Creeper Catgirl
    Creeper Catgirl 3 days ago +1

    i'm a pegion to

  • London qween miss London

    Patrick star looks like a boy putting mackup on but I'm not gonna be rude because anybody can put makeup on doesn't matter if your a boy or girl

  • Karissa Solsvik
    Karissa Solsvik 3 days ago

    U should mix your contour and powder stuff😁😂

  • Rosse Works
    Rosse Works 3 days ago

    “Don’t you mean... THIGH-dye?”

  • liyaah85
    liyaah85 3 days ago

    what a waste of makeup

  • Hailey Furr
    Hailey Furr 3 days ago

    James where are you

  • Yes boss
    Yes boss 3 days ago

    It’s so pretty

  • AarohiXO
    AarohiXO 3 days ago

    She should do an updated one with James Charles pallete

  • Lauren
    Lauren 3 days ago

    You didn’t DO JAMES CHARLES !!!!!!!!!!

  • Jade Sobish
    Jade Sobish 3 days ago

    I'm from Illinois too

  • Lvl 99 Mafia boss
    Lvl 99 Mafia boss 3 days ago

    "Six colors one cup"
    *me thinks about it*
    *me processing it*
    *me realizing how dirty the joke was*
    *five minutes later*

  • Deanna Spencer
    Deanna Spencer 3 days ago

    F you you did not include James Charles👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👿👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️☠️🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡🤡👺👺👺👺👺👺👺🔪🔪🔪🔪🔪🔪🔪🔪🔪🌡💉🌡💉💉💉💉💉🌡💉💉💉🌡🌡🌡🌡

    • Solo Sav
      Solo Sav 3 days ago


  • Hailee Romano
    Hailee Romano 3 days ago +1

    Beauty Gurus are quakeing

  • Zhoe Gomez
    Zhoe Gomez 4 days ago


    • Solo Sav
      Solo Sav 3 days ago

      Zhoe Gomez it wasn’t out yet

  • Evelyn Sanchez
    Evelyn Sanchez 4 days ago +1

    Who else is watching this after Jame Charles dropped his Palette

  • TOXIC Peach Pug
    TOXIC Peach Pug 4 days ago +2

    you should mix the other franken eyeshadow with that one

  • Sky Dragon
    Sky Dragon 4 days ago +1

    Dusty Dragon (eyeshadow edition)

    • Sky Dragon
      Sky Dragon 3 days ago

      I also commented this name for the franken sephora lipstick. That's why it says eyeshadow edition. :)

  • Quipy Bam
    Quipy Bam 4 days ago +1

    You did not do the James Charles palette😭

    • Quipy Bam
      Quipy Bam 3 days ago

      Solo Sav I am sorry I did not look at the date for the video

    • Solo Sav
      Solo Sav 3 days ago

      Quipy Bam it wasn’t out yet

  • Ashley Castillo
    Ashley Castillo 4 days ago +1

    you are the best you should try james Charles

  • klonaya
    klonaya 4 days ago +1

    me: ooooh this really would make a great asmr video!
    saf: maybe i should just stop talking and make some asmr video

  • Salma Bitar
    Salma Bitar 4 days ago +1

    One of the eye shadows was called subscribe I’m not lying

  • Vicky Le
    Vicky Le 4 days ago +1

    I died when Tyler said " *Huda Booty* " XD

  • mellow melon
    mellow melon 4 days ago +1

    kinda interested to see what perfumes mixed together might smell like

  • Helena Tabares
    Helena Tabares 4 days ago +2

    So sad because I watched this for the first time like 2 weeks after the James Charles palette came out NOOOOOOO Safiya so close, love you thought my mom also refers to you as her fav fashion youtuber ha!