Mixing Every Beauty Guru's Eyeshadow Palette Together

  • Published on Oct 31, 2018
  • Yes, we did this. So I have done a few bad makeup science experiments before with my own nude lipsticks, foundations, eyeshadows, liquid lipsticks, and highlighters, and I've also mixed together every lipstick from Sephora, but I wanted to think more dramatic this time, so I bought every online beauty guru's eyeshadow palette that was currently available, and we mixed them together into one Frankenguru eyeshadow. What do you think it should be named?
    Check out our merch here: fiendsbysaf.com/
    If your size is sold out, we're restocking ASAP so sign up for email updates!
    Game of Thrones Theme - Western Cover
    via BenDanProductions
    Kevin MacLeod - Sneaky Snitch
    Creative Commons - Attribution 3.0 Unported- CC BY 3.0
    Disclaimer: We only bought and mixed palettes that I could buy firsthand (still available from a credible retailer), so palettes that were released essentially from mid-2017 onwards. We also focused on gurus who post content primarily in English, just to keep it the experiment to one market.
    Aspyn Ovard x tarte
    Carmi x Makeup Revolution - Kiss Of Fire
    Carli Bybel x BH Cosmetics
    Chloe Morello x Ciate London - pretty, fun and fearless
    Chloe Morello x Pixi - Romantic Radiance
    Desi + Katy x Dose of Colors - Friendcation
    Dominique Cosmetics - Latte
    Dominique Cosmetics - Lemonade
    Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Needs
    Emily Noel x Makeup Revolution - The Wants
    Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - It's All Wild
    Eva Gutowski x Colourpop - Vacation Mode
    Huda Beauty - Amethyst Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Coral Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Desert Dusk
    Huda Beauty - Electric Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Emerald Obsessios
    Huda Beauty - Gemstone Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Mauve Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Warm Brown Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Rose Gold Remastered
    Huda Beauty - Ruby Obessions
    Huda Beauty - Sapphire Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Smokey Obsessions
    Huda Beauty - Topaz Obsessions
    iluvsarahii x Colourpop - $aucey
    iluvsarahii x Dose of Colors
    Imogenation x Makeup Revolution
    ItsJudyTime x Pixi - ItsEyeTime
    ItsMyRayeRaye x BH Cosmetics
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - The Jaclyn Hill Palette
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Armed & Gorgeous
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Bling Boss
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Dark Magic
    Jaclyn Hill x Morphe - Ring The Alarm
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Androgyny
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Beauty Killer
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Blood Sugar
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Thirsty
    Kandee Johnson x Too Faced - I Want Kandee
    Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - Dream St
    Kathleen Lights x Colourpop - The Zodiac
    Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Daydream
    Kristen Leanne x Urban Decay - Kaleidoscope Dream
    Laura Lee Los Angeles - Boss Babe
    Laura Lee Los Angeles - Cat's Pajamas
    Laura Lee Los Angeles - Nudie Patootie
    Laura Lee Los Angeles - Party Animal
    Makeup Geek - Always
    Makeup Geek - Forever
    Makeup Geek - I’m So Extra
    Makeup Geek - In The Nude
    Makeup Geek - Not So Basic
    Manny MUA Lunar Beauty - Life's A Drag
    Marzia x Winky Lux - Natura
    Marzia x Winky Lux - La Frutta
    Melissa Michelle x ULTA Beauty - Bring On The Glam
    Nicol Concilio x Violet Voss
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Goal Getter
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Heat Stroke
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Play With Me
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Stay With Me
    Patrick Starr x MAC - Sugah Mama
    Shaaanxo x BH Cosmetics - The Remix
    Shayla x Colourpop - Perception
    Shayla x Maybelline - The City Mini
    Soph x Makeup Revolution
    Soph x Makeup Revolution - Extra Spice
    Tammi x Makeup Revolution - Tropical Paradise
    Tanya Burr Cosmetics - Jingle & Mingle Night Palette
    Stacey Marie MUA x BPerfect Cosmetics
    Karrueche x Colourpop - She "Fem Rosa"
    BelleJorden x Makeup Revolution - Obsession Palette
    Some people say Norvina of ABH was once a Beauty TheXvidr, and she has a bunch of palettes.
    Karrueche x Colourpop - Brown Sugar
    Jeffree Star Cosmetics - Alien Palette
    Huda Beauty - New Nudes
    Amber Scholl - 24K Gold Eyeshadow Palette
    James Charles x Morphe - Unleash Your Inner Artist Palette
    Christen Dominique - Dominique Cosmetics Berries & Cream Palette
    But based on the color breakdowns of those palettes, I do not think that their presence would have drastically altered the final #Frankenguru color!
    This video is NOT sponsored!
    Safiya's Instagram: instagram.com/safiyany/
    Twitter: twitter.com/safiyajn
    Facebook: facebook.com/safnygaard/
    Assistant Editors: Emily Linden & Claire Wiley

Comments • 30 467

  • Safiya Nygaard
    Safiya Nygaard  5 months ago +19592

    HELLO FRIENDS!! yes, we did this. please look to the description for a list of palettes mixed and a running list of upcoming palettes that were not included! love u guys!! xoxo, saf

  • Pig And Bear
    Pig And Bear 54 minutes ago

    Plz make kids murch

  • fi rich
    fi rich Hour ago

    U missed james Charles

  • Amy Louise
    Amy Louise 6 hours ago

    Safiya needs her own palette ⬆️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

  • Frances Keane
    Frances Keane 13 hours ago

    what about the bh cosmetics sylvia ganipalette??????

  • Rosie Simpson
    Rosie Simpson 14 hours ago

    She had to make his right before James Charles releases his palette. 😂

  • Caroline Oberg
    Caroline Oberg 14 hours ago

    All y'all asking about James Charles palette can find your answer in the description. It was released/announced after filming the video.

  • JoJo Kaup
    JoJo Kaup 15 hours ago +1

    Do a full face of Frankenstein makeup

  • Master Fire
    Master Fire 16 hours ago +1

    4:24 that color though😍(there were a bunch of other pretty blue types of colors in the other palettes too of course. Blue is my fav color lol)

  • Mary Hopkins
    Mary Hopkins 17 hours ago +1

    *sad bc she missed James Charles* :(((((;

  • Zach Nil
    Zach Nil 18 hours ago +3

    Was James x Morphe out then? Coz if it was YOU MISSED IT GURL!
    If you are a sister press this button for everyone will know your there:

    • TheLaurenluv101
      TheLaurenluv101 10 hours ago

      In the description it says that it wasn't released when they were filming.

  • Morgan
    Morgan 20 hours ago

    What about James Charles

  • Nails Are Life
    Nails Are Life 20 hours ago

    All those JS stars disappearing...😭

  • swaggy swaggerson
    swaggy swaggerson 20 hours ago

    mix all of fentys foundation colours together

  • R Hobbs
    R Hobbs Day ago

    That's not even a teacup lol its a glass mug

  • Galaxy Unicorn Slimes

    You should do a full face of frankenstein make up

  • ThatStarWarsChick

    Saf what lipstick are you wearing?

  • Brooklynn Pruitt

    What about James Charles!?!

  • Lynne McGee
    Lynne McGee Day ago

    I haven't looked yet, but I hope the link to that plague video is in the description. omg... lol!

  • Sarah Golay
    Sarah Golay Day ago

    You most james Charles

  • fluffy unicorn bw
    fluffy unicorn bw Day ago +1

    14:46 what about James Charles

  • Pippa Mcy
    Pippa Mcy Day ago

    Is it just me who cracked up when saf said
    ‘Narrow dump’

  • Bob Stuart
    Bob Stuart 2 days ago

    "and this one is h💿l💿!"

  • Ashlynn Somers
    Ashlynn Somers 2 days ago


    just me?

  • Galaxy Tutorials
    Galaxy Tutorials 2 days ago

    Where was James Charles palate

  • Savanna Mercer
    Savanna Mercer 2 days ago

    What happened to james???

  • Elana Hochbaum
    Elana Hochbaum 2 days ago

    She looks so much like Karen Gillan here!!

  • Kauji Mondragoon
    Kauji Mondragoon 2 days ago

    They had blood sugar and I'm shook

  • Chance FatOdds
    Chance FatOdds 2 days ago

    22:05 The most creative way to slip in a shmash that like without saying shmash that like

  • Delaney Holsinger
    Delaney Holsinger 2 days ago


  • Trash Vlogs
    Trash Vlogs 2 days ago

    i figured it out. Safiya is trying to figure out what colours she should make her own eyeshadow palette yey

  • Abigail Nauta
    Abigail Nauta 2 days ago

    JAMES CHARLES!!!!!!!!!!!

  • tommythewelshy emma
    tommythewelshy emma 2 days ago

    James Charles

  • Aleksandra Pestner
    Aleksandra Pestner 2 days ago

    You look so cute with eut make up

  • Ian Cunningham
    Ian Cunningham 3 days ago

    You forgot James Charles

  • Diana-I NAILED IT
    Diana-I NAILED IT 3 days ago

    Where s James Charles?

  • hi hi
    hi hi 3 days ago

    So I'm the only one who noticed she got MARZIAS PALLETE?!?

  • Madeline Green
    Madeline Green 3 days ago +1

    How a
    How ar
    How are
    How are y
    How are yo
    How are you

  • AllaynaSkye TV
    AllaynaSkye TV 3 days ago

    Shimmering burgundy beauty

  • Bincy Rachel
    Bincy Rachel 3 days ago

    You should do a blooper video

  • Kaci Davies
    Kaci Davies 3 days ago

    HOW COULD YOU MISS JAMES CHARLES HE IS THE MAIN ONE!love you sorry i just had to say that xD

    • Kaci Davies
      Kaci Davies 2 days ago

      +Bob Stuart that isnt the point

    • Bob Stuart
      Bob Stuart 2 days ago

      Kaci Davies I don't think it was out when she filmed it

  • Pandora Spooky
    Pandora Spooky 3 days ago

    Am I the only one upset that there are no James Charles pallet

  • Fae the Gae
    Fae the Gae 3 days ago +1

    *sits waiting to see Jeffree star pallettes*
    *sees them*
    *dies inside coz Jeffree is a queen*

  • Dolly CT
    Dolly CT 3 days ago

    You missed James Charles I'm so sister shook

  • Jacqueline Watson
    Jacqueline Watson 3 days ago

    James Charles?...

  • leigh p
    leigh p 3 days ago

    I'm still waiting for safs makeup line

  • PastelPaw PolarPanda

    78.7% of your channel is about makeup.

  • Sonja Simovic
    Sonja Simovic 3 days ago +1

    Like if agree

  • Sonja Simovic
    Sonja Simovic 3 days ago +1

    I think that you shuld make an eyeshadow, a lipstick and a highlighter called the frankinstain collection or safty collection

  • Bellatheweirdo
    Bellatheweirdo 3 days ago

    Are you gonna keep them all?

  • Dead_ Inside
    Dead_ Inside 3 days ago


  • I Told You Earlier
    I Told You Earlier 3 days ago +3

    When she said no shade just science. I just rolled my eyes and said but theres loads of shades. EyEsHaDoW sHaDeS

  • Madison Kunze
    Madison Kunze 3 days ago

    You should do a full face of your frankenmakeup

  • JKCrafts :p
    JKCrafts :p 4 days ago

    I’m from Illinois and in Illinois

  • Dippy_DoT_Mann
    Dippy_DoT_Mann 4 days ago

    *tHaTs wHAt hE saID*

  • Marielle Riordan
    Marielle Riordan 4 days ago

    You should totally make your own palette 🤩

  • Slothipus .32
    Slothipus .32 4 days ago

    Your so funny but what do you do with the palettes once you've finished this video.

  • Libby Thorburn
    Libby Thorburn 4 days ago

    You should call the eye shadow tea bag

  • Busra Jarin
    Busra Jarin 4 days ago

    Safiya's bank has entered the chat

  • Busra Jarin
    Busra Jarin 4 days ago +2

    You should do mixing all my blush and bronzer and then make a full face of Frankenstein makeup

  • Twin Twin
    Twin Twin 4 days ago

    I love Marvel but good joke safia

  • amalia Amelia
    amalia Amelia 4 days ago +1

    Was the James Charles Pallet existing when you were filming?

  • Artist Games
    Artist Games 4 days ago

    U should make a part 2 to this safiya because they have alot more palettes now and i want to see the new most chosen color for their palettes

  • Crystal Ballinger
    Crystal Ballinger 4 days ago

    Lol 11:58

  • Nicol Castro
    Nicol Castro 4 days ago

    What about James Charles x morphe

  • Natayla Magistrado
    Natayla Magistrado 4 days ago

    Jefree star idk if hes in this

  • Emma Pollak
    Emma Pollak 4 days ago


  • Sharon Tackett
    Sharon Tackett 4 days ago

    I want the fixie kit!!!!!

  • Glenda Diaz
    Glenda Diaz 4 days ago

    Omg 💜 this color you made

  • Madison Wira
    Madison Wira 4 days ago

    Only if sister James launched his earlier

  • Evy And Hope Besties Forever


  • Jury El Sharawy
    Jury El Sharawy 4 days ago +3

    "It's a very pretty pallet"
    Destroys the whole thing

  • UglyTraffic Cone
    UglyTraffic Cone 4 days ago

    you should mix every soap from bath and body worlds together

  • Jenni MSP
    Jenni MSP 4 days ago +2

    who wants her to use all her mixed products in one video?

  • Super Sisters
    Super Sisters 5 days ago

    I am english

  • Kat Playz
    Kat Playz 5 days ago +3


    *shadow, shadow, shadow*

  • Laura Domoradzka
    Laura Domoradzka 5 days ago

    You should produce a makeup line using all your averages and percentages to create the ‘perfect’ line!

  • R¡cha El¡zabeth
    R¡cha El¡zabeth 5 days ago

    How much money did huda get after this?

  • Cornelia Vejrup
    Cornelia Vejrup 5 days ago

    I really want that jacket
    The Patrick Star one

  • Kawaii UltimaAphYT
    Kawaii UltimaAphYT 5 days ago

    I’m dying from when Tyler said

    *hUDa bOoTY*

  • pizza cat
    pizza cat 5 days ago

    How about "ultimate collab" for a name? Just to put a funny twist on it

  • Mali Hamilton
    Mali Hamilton 5 days ago


  • Philippa Charlotte Rockefeller


  • Justin Scapi.o
    Justin Scapi.o 5 days ago

    James Charles?

  • Peri Goldblatt
    Peri Goldblatt 6 days ago

    i think ive watched this video like a dozen times. its still funny every time. as with every franken makeup video. i can watch them over and over

  • Cassandra yome
    Cassandra yome 6 days ago

    Where's James Charles?

  • Jewels Skurka
    Jewels Skurka 6 days ago

    James Charles pallet comes out the next week.

  • Rainbow Galaxy
    Rainbow Galaxy 6 days ago

    My name's Shayla

  • josie aguilar
    josie aguilar 6 days ago

    Oh u r sick so sowwy

    FUN GAMER TMUNG 6 days ago

    This is very good colour

  • Artistic _Sunny
    Artistic _Sunny 6 days ago

    Go NZ!!

  • Drew Jasso
    Drew Jasso 6 days ago

    U should call it all the teas

  • Anti-Social Practice Club

    All the dislikes are from the beauty gurus

  • Marie Martinez
    Marie Martinez 6 days ago

    wait is james charles ?

  • Ella C
    Ella C 6 days ago

    What about James Charles

  • Abby Shufeldt
    Abby Shufeldt 6 days ago

    You forgot James Charles

  • Meldoesmakeup
    Meldoesmakeup 6 days ago

    Your makeup looks beautiful with the frankenguru shadow! Wow your eyes are poppin 👀

  • Twenty One Pilots Trash

    *WHy DiD yOu DrInK pOwDeR?*

  • Oof Aves
    Oof Aves 7 days ago

    Is anyone else concerned that she DIDNT DO JAMES CHARLES?!?!?!?!

    • Ekru
      Ekru 5 days ago

      I don't think his pallet was released at the time of this video so.....

  • Purple_pickle TV
    Purple_pickle TV 7 days ago

    Why no James Charles