• Published on Dec 19, 2017
  • This isn't so much a review of Star Wars: The Last Jedi as it is a discussion starter on how Lucasfilm's approach to building the new Star Wars trilogy is fundamentally flawed.
    Warning, the video contains spoilers for The Last Jedi and The Force Awakens.
    ➤Twitter: @AndreiTerbea
    ➤Instagram: @AndreiTerbea
  • Film & AnimationFilm & Animation

Comments • 6 207

  • Austin Johnsen
    Austin Johnsen 5 days ago

    There exists a clip of Mark Hamil saying that JJ had a much different vision for Episode 8, so make of that what you will.

  • L1GHT D3M0N
    L1GHT D3M0N 14 days ago

    George Lucas: *Sells Lucasfilm to Disney*
    **Earth just lost its best defender**

  • William Dale
    William Dale 22 days ago

    Oh god she’s a skywalker

  • Carl Sandoff
    Carl Sandoff 29 days ago

    Tbh I don’t actually think there’s a clash of vision between these Two directors. If you listen to Abrams talking about how he preferes to make movies, he constanlty mentions this Idea of mystery boxes within the films. I don’t think J.J. Really had a plan for the trilogy, actually no one had, Lucasfilm has confirmed that they are making these movies on at a time, leaving room for the next director to fill out gaps and continue the story. The reason we expected things to to go the way we expected, with Rey’s parents and Snoke, has to with all of these theories and how the previous trilogies have treated simillar subjects, like the importance of The emperor and Luke’s parents.

  • Jbomb 360
    Jbomb 360 Month ago

    Wait someone actually enjoy The last Jedi

  • Amil Chenganakkattil

    Episode 9 is called *rise of the skywalker* , if that isn’t funny, I don’t know what is

  • Edox the Infinite
    Edox the Infinite Month ago

    Actually, it's not Lucasfilm who's making these mistakes. It's Disney.

    UNICONIC NAME Month ago

    i thought snape was the guy in the thumbnail

  • The B0xol
    The B0xol Month ago +1

    It’s Disney’s fault

  • Krystal Barnett
    Krystal Barnett Month ago

    Couldn't believe they killed Luke..that was it for me!!

  • Pedro Santos
    Pedro Santos Month ago

    Well the two first episodes of the prequels sucked but Revenge of the sith was great

  • Ragu San
    Ragu San Month ago

    I always cry when I think about that Ray's parent's sold Ray to a slave trader in a desert planet to become a slave to tyrants.

  • Yo Man
    Yo Man Month ago

    2:48 The new episode is called "Rise of Skywalker". I think you nailed it.

  • [1H04] Frauchiger Adrian

    I feel that Disney is the reason for the downfall of Star Wars

  • 219adi
    219adi Month ago

    I Fell Asleep When I Watched The Movie

  • Nazik Adam
    Nazik Adam Month ago

    Original story
    Same transaction from master to pupil (Luke to Rey)
    Would be great.

  • James B
    James B Month ago

    Rey cant be a Skywalker because it takes away from Kylo who is the villain and a Skywalker. Look at the Skywalker track record... The Skywalkers are the villains of the series. Anakin and Kylo. Luke is a coward who ran off hid while he let the great evil in Kylo grow to power. Luke doesnt deserve the glory. He owed them the final save and he could die in peace. Rey will be the hero Luke failed to be. Kylo Ren remains the bad guy you love to hate and he has the balls to do what needs done even if he does defect to rebels. (Unlike Luke who was scared to kill Kylo)

    THE CP18 CHANNEL 2 months ago

    I just want to point out lucas films has been bought by disney

  • Grigory Fazz
    Grigory Fazz 2 months ago

    The entire film was just one big mistake

  • Bili Brig
    Bili Brig 2 months ago

    LOTR the best movie after hobbit

  • Subelite
    Subelite 2 months ago

    B-b-but wat about Rey miss I can do anything bitch

  • Shea zzstu Warner
    Shea zzstu Warner 2 months ago

    3:20 Actually, the scripts for all three movies WERE finished. However, Ep. 7 got criticized for being a carbon copy of Ep. 4, so they got Rian Johnson to make Ep. 8 different. I believe what Lucasfilm should have done was look at JJ's script and tell him to make it different than the other films.

  • Slayerlord0
    Slayerlord0 2 months ago

    "Hopefully they'll treat it and other future Star Wars projects less like The Hobbit and more like Lord of the Rings."
    So you mean by treating it and those who support the projects (i.e. the fans) with respect?
    *laughs maniacally*
    In all seriousness, I don't have much hope in this. Kennedy and Johnson's smugness and the way they publicly put down fans and dismiss criticism as "misogyny," is disgusting, and displays an astounding lack of professionalism and artistic integrity. It's this kind of behavior that pushed me from simply disliking The Last Jedi to outright hating it. It seems very unlikely that Star Wars films are going to get any better so long as Disney and Lucasfilm keeps putting people who think they're that far above it all in charge. We as fans have given George Lucas so much flack for the Prequels, but at least he's always been capable of improving from past mistakes. The Prequels did improve with each installment, if for no other reason than because Lucas listened when people complained about Jar Jar. Here we have a huge dip in quality from one film to the next, and the ones responsible act like they deserve a medal for refusing to obey the most basic rules of storytelling and for treating the people who love and support the franchise like dirt.
    Can JJ make the save with episode 9? Probably not. Wrenching the film back to how he wanted it would require retconning or at least ignoring big chunks of Last Jedi, and that's going to hurt narrative structure. Building off of Last Jedi's additions would be the best course of action, but that has its own problems. The best course of action would be to just throw Last Jedi out entirely and do Episode 8 over, but that's almost certainly not going to happen. I really hope I'm wrong, and that JJ will find a way to pull off something spectacular, but...well...we'll see, I guess.

  • TheRealJD 22
    TheRealJD 22 2 months ago

    It's Disney's fault

  • Locke Carmichael
    Locke Carmichael 2 months ago

    The hobbit is a great fucking series bit harsh

  • Dee Dial
    Dee Dial 2 months ago

    I came in late in the Star Wars fandom and immediately left after the terrible execution of TLJ and failing to create memorable characters with the new actors for this trilogy. I'll be sure to watch episode IX when it comes on Redbox or a two dollar movie bend.

  • Dav Free
    Dav Free 2 months ago

    JJ might course correct, but he’ll keep Luke irrelevant. Remember, JJ removed Hans character growth and turned him into a dead beat dad and estranged husband before he killed him. Ford may have wanted it... but there is a reason why the trinity of Han, Luke and Leia never appeared on screen together...
    And frankly, the idea that a screen writer couldn’t find a story where Luke didn’t overpower the movie is insulting to screen writers, which JJ is not.
    Anyway, JJ now doesn’t have to kill off Luke. Which means the systematic removal of legacy characters is nearing completion. And when there is no more reason to make toy moulds of Han, Luke and Leia, Finn, Poe and Rey will have more chance to be picked up off the toy shelf.

  • Paul's Parlour
    Paul's Parlour 2 months ago

    The Hobbit movies are way better than the Last Jedi.

    • shakotoon
      shakotoon 2 months ago

      Of course they are. Heck, even the SW Holiday Special is better, and that's saying a lot.

  • Vladlen Volkov
    Vladlen Volkov 2 months ago

    ...disney kill sw...

  • Barry Allen
    Barry Allen 2 months ago

    This is actually the first time I watched any of your videos. It was actually pretty nice to see things from your prospective. I my self don't think it has very much to do with how fast they rushed things. The people who wrote put in charge of the Star Wars franchise never actually cared about it to begin with. They literally stated that they don't care about the old fans and just want to make new ones, followed by them saying that if people don't like their new SW movies or the messages they put in them that it's too bad because they don't need negativity shown toward them. They even blamed the lack of product placement for the record breaking lack of audiences during Han Solo A Star Wars Story. They retconed the continuity from every canan before The Force Awakens just because they didn't like it because it wasn't PC enough and needed less white men and more racial diversity, more women, and LGTBQ representation, and continued on by changing character's personalities to better fit their message. These people where never even trying to make the movies entertaining. They literally made my entertainment their last priority. Whatever they lacked in entertainment they just added bad jokes, random anticlimactic events, randomly killed off characters from the original trilogy, bad lightsaber fights, interesting yet pointless clips, and their only good looking sequence in the Last Jedai that doesn't even make any sense, creating plot holes all over their backwards continuity.

  • Reed McKinney
    Reed McKinney 2 months ago

    You went WAY too easy on this piece of shit. “We’ll just have to wait till episode 9 to judge the trilogy as a whole”. No, that is defeatist and excusatory. This movie is dog shit, no amount of corrections can undo this fuckup. Star Wars is lame now, that’s all there is to it.

  • Kidrocker Videos
    Kidrocker Videos 2 months ago


  • Emerald Tech
    Emerald Tech 2 months ago +1

    There is a difference between disliking a movie and completely harassing someone online.
    You know who you are. Glares

  • toshdeluxe dr.
    toshdeluxe dr. 3 months ago

    Sadly that audiences didn’t liked the last Jedi

  • qutaiba Hamdan
    qutaiba Hamdan 3 months ago

    the last jedi and the whole new trilogy is an abomination, please dont even try to defend or be objective around them. this whole trilogy is terrible leadership.

  • Terius Zúñiga
    Terius Zúñiga 3 months ago

    0:09 I've been looking forward to this.

  • Yayman Yayman
    Yayman Yayman 3 months ago

    I liked the last jedi but the casino scene was really bad dont hate on me it is just my opinion

  • Jeff Greenwade
    Jeff Greenwade 3 months ago

    Lol, the sequel trilogies are ass now. Damn shame.

  • Coffee & Comics
    Coffee & Comics 3 months ago +1

    Thank you captain obvious

  • Cara Marais
    Cara Marais 3 months ago

    I actually loved tlj
    But i did not like tfa

  • Some Guy's Channel
    Some Guy's Channel 3 months ago

    I just realised:
    You draw your eyes like Bendy's.

  • JJ souls
    JJ souls 3 months ago

    Terrable movie. Stupid villains. And starwars has the best villans

  • Riski Rills
    Riski Rills 3 months ago

    that's why you should not change the director in middle of trilogy

  • Shreerang Vaidya
    Shreerang Vaidya 3 months ago +1

    Which all colours can you see?

  • Ur Mom
    Ur Mom 3 months ago

    December 19th is my birthday

  • Actualyolo
    Actualyolo 3 months ago

    why do every one hate this movie ?

  • Oh Yeah Yeah
    Oh Yeah Yeah 3 months ago

    the last jedi was horrible compared to revenge of the wilfur

  • Knut Roar Røyseth
    Knut Roar Røyseth 3 months ago

    OMG. Where was willfur? 😂😂😂

  • King Lightbulb
    King Lightbulb 3 months ago

    Honestly I think it would have been better to leave it at episode VI. VII was okay, but it was a bit of a stretch. However, VIII ruined everything

  • Hicham Cherqaoui
    Hicham Cherqaoui 3 months ago

    Roundhead Johnson really damaged the whole franchise.

  • TheDarkFart
    TheDarkFart 3 months ago

    I really hope they remaster the last jedi


    Nope Disney ruined it

  • Mehul Desai
    Mehul Desai 4 months ago

    I didn't like LOTR but I see where you're coming from

  • master of comedy
    master of comedy 4 months ago

    Oh no no

  • Hayden Hamlin
    Hayden Hamlin 4 months ago

    This video speaks so much for the Star Wars Community. Thank you, Andrei. It was equally disappointing to wait two years just for Luke to throw a Lightsaber behind his back.

  • kilroy987
    kilroy987 4 months ago

    What went wrong is no one reviewed what could be done with the material after the movie or what was being done with the material that came before. Why did they think this guy deserved a trilogy? What rock have they been under?

  • Sydxds SW
    Sydxds SW 4 months ago

    I hope she is not a Skywalker.

  • Joseph Veevers
    Joseph Veevers 4 months ago

    I quite like The Last Jedi, it tries something new rather than following the formula. TFA was just a retread of ANH and im not too bothered about it but you've gotta give TLJ credit for doing something new with it. There is flaws that the movie suffers from but what movie doesn't have flaws? As a movie fan and a Star Wars fan, I really enjoyed the movie.

  • Hatchetforce
    Hatchetforce 4 months ago

    What went wrong? Everything.

  • bunnyfreakz
    bunnyfreakz 4 months ago

    TLJ is not only bad movie but really bizarre movie. It's looks like parody.

  • Rares Sava
    Rares Sava 4 months ago

    You right! This trilogy could be better if they made a plan. But there is still material that could giva a great Episode 9. I like TFA and I love TLJ and I can't wait what this trilogy will end.

  • The Makuta
    The Makuta 4 months ago

    The actual problem is Ryan Johnson antagonized the older parts of the fan base by his various attempts to marginalize them. Then he took to much away from the cannon and made his story seem like a glorified fanfic with politics

  • PsychosithS Dead skin rippers

    Kathleen Kennedy is the problem. Why can't nobody see the elephant in the room?

  • Lezzerplayz Games
    Lezzerplayz Games 4 months ago

    I don’t care about the spoilers

  • Boston Hunter
    Boston Hunter 4 months ago

    The Last Jedi is the Halo 5 of Star Wars

  • BigNick 1864
    BigNick 1864 4 months ago

    Everything went wrong!!

  • Jim Woods
    Jim Woods 4 months ago

    It all comes down to basic storytelling: setups and payoffs. TLJ also really feels rushed, and RJ did everything he could to piss off the fans by "killing the past." Can't do that well when the story already has basic rules and expectations that go with it. No one told RJ "No, that's a bad idea, it doesn't make any sense."

  • randomshittutorials
    randomshittutorials 4 months ago +1

    *LUCKILY* the infinite power of direction is going to the force awakens director, NOT the last Jedi director.
    (You animated that wrong)
    Thank GOD.

  • jamesgames
    jamesgames 4 months ago

    Me want George Lucas back no stupid Disney ever since it was sold to Disney there was no severed limbs

    • Rares Sava
      Rares Sava 4 months ago

      See, there is the problem: When the prequels arived, fans bullied George Lucas until he gave up on SW. But after TLJ, fans harass the people involved in the sequels and want George Lucas back. At this point George probably saw how
      hypocritical are the fans. I don't know if you know, but OT wasn't made entirely by George, but the prequels are made only by him and it was a

  • MJPK
    MJPK 4 months ago

    the movies are terrible. rehash and dumb slow speed chase with dumb "gotcha" moments are just that awful

  • Mr. Spider The Bug
    Mr. Spider The Bug 4 months ago

    Comon people. Are you seriously? Star Wars is dead. And after damage that Disney did, no director or script already can't save him. Only if someone buys the rights, and says that all Disney films are not cannon. this don't happen, not in this millennium. SW is dead, the end.

    • Rares Sava
      Rares Sava 4 months ago

      No. Expandet stuff allready gave more details about the questions people have. All they need to do for now on is put them into movies. I didn't get why SW is ruinned by a movie that can be easily fixed. That's just boiling hate.

  • AAG 23
    AAG 23 4 months ago

    Every PS4 player knows that X was after

  • Dagobert Duck
    Dagobert Duck 4 months ago

    WAIT... They shot the whole lotr trilogy in ONE Session??? Fuck... thats a lot of work.

  • J4CKT1C4L
    J4CKT1C4L 4 months ago +1

    Watch "Solo A Star Wars movie" it's awesome!
    (my opinion)

  • Chronocide
    Chronocide 4 months ago

    So you think giving an incompetent director MORE power will turn his "vision" into a hit? You're an idiot.

    • Chronocide
      Chronocide 4 months ago

      +Rares Sava Sure and I think he is an incompetent director that has no respect for the fans. Also, not liking someone and having a contrary opinion does not make one full of hate.

    • Rares Sava
      Rares Sava 4 months ago

      Umm... have you ever wathced another RJ movie, or you are full of hate?

  • Chronocide
    Chronocide 4 months ago

    The Last Jedi was nothing more than an idiot sjw gleefully giving the finger to the fans for no other reason than to piss off as many people as possible while Kennedy attempts to make the entirety of the franchise one big feminist FU bow down to wahmen.

  • Bryan Steele
    Bryan Steele 4 months ago

    I like your video, but I just have one bit of critique of it. You compare the sequel trilogy to the Lord of the rings. Here is the major difference between the two. The lord of the rings is 3 movies based on 3 books that been around for like 70 years at that point. The star wars sequel trilogy and it's story was given the green light in the fall of 2012, and expected to have its first entry in May of 2015. 2 years and 5 months later is no time to prepare for that. I think the LOTR trilogy spent just that on filming. You wanna blame someone, blame bob iger

  • migo rollo
    migo rollo 4 months ago

    I mean TLJ sorry😁

  • migo rollo
    migo rollo 4 months ago +1

    What went wrong with TLG??? everything!!!!!!! RJ is stupid jj is better

  • Momo Ali
    Momo Ali 4 months ago +3

    Don't forget the forced agenda

  • Kong Kwan
    Kong Kwan 5 months ago

    I thought the thumbnail was Snape lol

  • Manuel XDXDXD _-_
    Manuel XDXDXD _-_ 5 months ago

    You should have more subscribers 4 this great content

  • Jason Miera
    Jason Miera 5 months ago


  • Evan James
    Evan James 5 months ago

    I really like the last Jedi so if that's your opinion its fine I respect it
    Like rey being Mary sue is weird because Luke and anakin is Mary sue too

  • A person
    A person 5 months ago

    I agree

  • Ignacio Chirinos
    Ignacio Chirinos 5 months ago

    And the director of the IX is.......... JJ

  • RiotGaming
    RiotGaming 5 months ago

    Rian is my Biggest Fan Director Of Star Wars, I hope Rian Will Direct Episode 9 Star Wars

  • Nikki Matthewd
    Nikki Matthewd 5 months ago +1

    Let's be real here JJ adams should of been the director of the whole trilogy

  • xakoswja jdjdjrvs
    xakoswja jdjdjrvs 5 months ago +2


    The thumbnail is


  • Theoddballguy
    Theoddballguy 5 months ago +1

    To me that was the biggest problem with the last Jedi.

  • ChrisTuckerexpress
    ChrisTuckerexpress 5 months ago +1

    1- Rey says her parents were nobody. Not Kylo. Why so many people miss this?
    2- Daisy said JJ told her Rey's parents would be nobody.
    3- JJ was a producer on 9 and loved Rian's script.
    4- Not every movie needs character development. The Bond movies and the Indiana Jones, most famously, lack character development. And of course, Seinfeld was famous for lacking character development.
    5- The real problem with these movies is that they lack entertaining characters other than Snoke and Kylo.

    • Rares Sava
      Rares Sava 5 months ago +1

      ChrisTuckerexpress I love TLJ

  • Team Tundra 2
    Team Tundra 2 6 months ago +2

    I thought the film was very good actually. Not amazing but good. But I can’t really see these inconsistencies in the way others can.

  • Sergi Medina
    Sergi Medina 6 months ago +1

    You're totally right, sir.
    But Rian Johnson is one of the worst directors I know. Ever since I watched _Looper_ I saw he's not as good as he claims to be... Who and why in the world someone hired him to direct (AND write!!!!) a _Star Wars_ movie is beyond my comprehension. And he's going to direct (AND write!!!!) the next trilogy!!!! Yes, even AFTER _The Last Jedi!!!!_

    • Rares Sava
      Rares Sava 4 months ago

      Well this trilogy could be better because he allready knew what to expect if he make mistakes.

  • Alejandro Villalba
    Alejandro Villalba 6 months ago

    Giving R Johnson a trilogy is one of the worse mistakes in the history of cinema. That guy has no clue about how to write and his ideas are terrible to say the least. Get him back to direct junkies stories. Fantasy is not his stuff.

  • Badri
    Badri 6 months ago

    👍🏿 Agree, I think we have the same opinion but its Rian Johnson's fault.

  • Ed Ford
    Ed Ford 6 months ago

    Star wars is broken.

    THE16THPHANTOM 6 months ago

    this was the first time i heard of that directory who F.A.Qed up the star wars universe. first impression were not great, all the sudden he is publically antagonizing fans, belittling them, made it all about sexism, later racism. just about the worst type of person to represent anything. i was like, ok rip star wars, i was not there for the originals 3 and i never really bothered with them but i was hopping to get into this new starwars. and what a shit show this has all turned out to be. now all of the sudden star wars is for women only, or was it the force that was for women only. crashing dissappointment is what the whole experience has been, thank god there are Marvel movies and Brainless fun Fast and Furious.

    SMIWAVE 6 months ago

    Нет уж. Своими новостями они снова хотят обмануть людей пойти на их очерендную многобюджетную замануху. В самом начале дисней публично заявляли что "они будут снимать фильмы по ЗВ пока они не перестанут приносить деньги" Этот момент пришёл, не надо ходить на девятый эпизод

  • Jim of Aotearoa
    Jim of Aotearoa 6 months ago

    At least they got the title right....."The Last Jedi" movie i'll ever pay for....

  • Comic Sans
    Comic Sans 6 months ago

    How bout these guns tho