I Let Strangers Pick My Makeup

  • Published on Jul 14, 2017
  • I went back to the mall and had strangers pick out a full face of new makeup for me to try and mix up my makeup look - from foundation to lipstick and everything in between! What do you guys think? How did they do? This is a second installment to when I let strangers pick my outfit - maybe I should wear both looks together!
    Don’t forget to click the bell to turn on post notifications!
    This video is NOT sponsored!
    A big thank you to everyone who helped me pick out my makeup look!
    Safiya's Nextbeat: nextbeat.co/u/safiya
    IG: instagram.com/safiyany/
    Twitter: twitter.com/safiyajn
    Facebook: facebook.com/safnygaard/
    Mind The Gap
    Get With The Funk
    Move To The Groove
    Fire And Ice
    Jerk Stuff
    Mesmers Fantasy
    Very Naughty Boy
    via Audio Network
    via AudioBlocks

Comments • 7 239

  • Safiya Nygaard
    Safiya Nygaard  Year ago +7437

    HELLO FRIENDS!! what do u guys think of my new makeup look?? and let me know if you got a notif for this video :). SO MUCH LOVE, safiya

    • Josephanie Ackman
      Josephanie Ackman 8 days ago

      You tried LipSense, I’d love for you to try our eye makeup to see if it lives up to the LipSense challenge!

    • Shilah Lewis
      Shilah Lewis 23 days ago

      I love you
      You are the best

    • Rowan Blanchard
      Rowan Blanchard 2 months ago

      I think it's really cute. You look like you could be a business man in summer🍉

    • Chicken Nuggets
      Chicken Nuggets 3 months ago +1

      Wassup. Srsly I think whatever makeup you try u look amazing in it! I did get notifications a Year Ago! I would have watched it early but I was rly bussy and forgot about it.. So sorry. LOVE U!

    • Morgan and emma Muffin
      Morgan and emma Muffin 3 months ago

      hi Queen Safiya

    STOPWARS 15 hours ago

    dude you look so gorgeous with all those crazy colors you should do wacky color combinations more often

  • Tina Yu
    Tina Yu Day ago

    Yayeeeeeee I’m Tina
    So....... I wAs IN thE vIdeO?

  • Tina Yu
    Tina Yu Day ago

    I need to talk to America’s parents


  • Hey Guys It’s Me Julia

    The eyeliner would look really pretty as lipstick or eyeshadow

  • Hanate Monstas
    Hanate Monstas 4 days ago

    At the risk of coming off as mildly sexist, that guy picked a really good eyeliner

  • Jenny Ta
    Jenny Ta 5 days ago

    wow i freaking LOVE the look

  • xXNyaIsYoGurl Xx
    xXNyaIsYoGurl Xx 7 days ago


  • Kate Jennings
    Kate Jennings 7 days ago

    3:14 flashback Mary 😂😂

  • Isabella Corrigal
    Isabella Corrigal 8 days ago

    Derek is now iconic 😂

  • Annie 7216
    Annie 7216 12 days ago

    Why did u get kicked out😮

  • Roberta Fisher
    Roberta Fisher 13 days ago

    I liked the green eyeliner........Erm, I liked the green eyeliner xxxx

  • Drenma
    Drenma 13 days ago

    The eyeshadow is crazy 😍

  • Molly Macioch
    Molly Macioch 14 days ago

    At 3:00 the mirror says holographic glow Simplynailogical is happy

  • Leah Ginsburg
    Leah Ginsburg 14 days ago


  • kat chirstian
    kat chirstian 15 days ago

    Tbh she was worst in buzzfes

  • Poppy Rose
    Poppy Rose 15 days ago

    I could never do this like how do you just ask random people

    I have intense social anxiety

  • Galatea Lagersten
    Galatea Lagersten 16 days ago

    " so, im here with dAnieL aNd aMeRikA "/#

  • Nora Csiszar
    Nora Csiszar 16 days ago

    "Sometimes you just need to glitter" YES Safiya!

  • Jaki Poloai
    Jaki Poloai 17 days ago

    Why did they kick u out just cuz of that

  • Sami ._. Blu
    Sami ._. Blu 17 days ago

    Can you ask KIDS to choose your outfit, makeup, etc? Please like so Saf can see.

  • cameronzemail
    cameronzemail 18 days ago

    To me, I think of a Summer goth.

  • shook kookies
    shook kookies 18 days ago +1

    Saf now has 3 pink the towns.

  • Crazy Elegant Majectical Unicorn

    When she said she had "America's Badunkadunk" I was like "Woah you only just met the girl!"

  • Cmc C
    Cmc C 18 days ago +5

    Everything was unconsciously influenced by ur shirt...

  • Sarah Dale
    Sarah Dale 18 days ago

    daniel and america... nice names lol.joking. just intrigued

  • kzragdoll
    kzragdoll 19 days ago

    Have you tried the flex menstrual disc?? Please try it!

  • Gracie Girl
    Gracie Girl 19 days ago

    You can't get rid of pink the town

  • Camille Pelletier
    Camille Pelletier 20 days ago +1

    is it just me or when safiya had the foundation and the eyeshadow i've seriously got vibe of kabuki makeup

  • Toasty Valdex
    Toasty Valdex 20 days ago

    5:26 the girls face when he says it looks nice

  • three awsome kids fun
    three awsome kids fun 23 days ago

    u r crazy i love it

  • Lucy Cunningham
    Lucy Cunningham 26 days ago

    Now saf needs to get a dog and name it Budunkidunk

  • Erica Lenhart
    Erica Lenhart 28 days ago

    I hope that lipstick was vaccinated...

  • Annika Hoag
    Annika Hoag 28 days ago

    At 6:50 y’all are right in the front of the eyeliner display from the “Picking My Makeup Blindfolded” video....I think I have a problem

  • Lorelei Van Tuyl
    Lorelei Van Tuyl 29 days ago

    Saf cannot escape Pink The Town

  • Lily John
    Lily John Month ago

    Kat von d? :(

  • Maria Zareva
    Maria Zareva Month ago

    I have the ever lasting liquid lipstick by kat von d in the colour Roxy

  • Margret Rena Bonita
    Margret Rena Bonita Month ago +1

    Oh my gosh! To meet Safiya AND talk makeup = fangirl screaming.

  • Abril Bedoya
    Abril Bedoya Month ago

    Love the look!

  • Tiya’s Glam Lounge

    I am at that point where I just ‘like’ safiya’s videos before even watching them 😂

  • Mike the random Mike the slam

    The girl behind her at 5:40 looks like Liza Koshy

  • Eve Wilson
    Eve Wilson Month ago

    When Safia said she was a bird, who else kind of wanted her to say "Wadup T-shirt reference!"

  • Jalissa Jal
    Jalissa Jal Month ago

    I definitely wouldn’t have picked a bright color. I would’ve picked more brown tones. Maybe for a main color a reddish color.

  • Annishka Deshmukh
    Annishka Deshmukh Month ago +2

    Safiya in the thumbnail was literally me as a baby when someone took my toys or things.

  • Krazy K
    Krazy K Month ago

    I just realized that Tyler has such a steady hand when he is holding something (like a camera).

  • Ann Nee
    Ann Nee Month ago

    I was always taught to either do bonkers eye or bonkers lip never both... But what do I know😏

  • Kiwi. Loves.Sloths
    Kiwi. Loves.Sloths Month ago +1

    6:33 Wow...I love her name!

  • happy_cactus
    happy_cactus Month ago

    Pause at 1:53 and look at her cup

  • NaviNovaNewbie
    NaviNovaNewbie Month ago

    Derek is the best human

  • Jessica Reyes
    Jessica Reyes Month ago

    Dont worry I like it too lol

  • Heather Jay
    Heather Jay Month ago +1

    I will pick a black lipstick

  • Alice B
    Alice B Month ago

    Best word in the video: Interesting.

  • Katie Tikao
    Katie Tikao Month ago

    I love how encouraging Saf is to the people picking out the makeup ❤️ great video as always, love your content! I’ve been binge watching these videos lately haha they’re so good.

  • Holo HH
    Holo HH Month ago


  • Sophie Mather
    Sophie Mather Month ago

    Everyone is hyping up Derek but everyone seems to have forgotten about Daniel!!

  • Blackglitter Rain
    Blackglitter Rain Month ago

    His name is not Daniel, it’s Maxon, get it right

  • taslima begum
    taslima begum Month ago +3

    Who else loves how Safiya says 'SHMASH' and 'ACHECK' ??? 😂😂😂

  • Woofie Does Art
    Woofie Does Art Month ago

    i hate everything about this look,you look like you belong on the highway

  • Hope Stout
    Hope Stout Month ago

    “Are you hungry?” Favorite thing said

  • Hope Stout
    Hope Stout Month ago

    Daniel checking himself out in the mirror 😂

  • Mackenzie Wilkie
    Mackenzie Wilkie 2 months ago

    You and Tyler seem like people who could make friends with anybody:). Thanks for being awesome!!

  • WolfBoi Animations
    WolfBoi Animations 2 months ago


  • Nyx TheFox
    Nyx TheFox 2 months ago

    I’ve had people ask if I was Nyx The Fox for the Nyx makeup brand
    It’s not...

  • G and A Sisters
    G and A Sisters 2 months ago

    I don't want to be rude, but is this girl named America??

  • Cat all Do
    Cat all Do 2 months ago


  • Georgia Ruff
    Georgia Ruff 2 months ago

    your a lot like Moriah elizebeth you should collab. the only problem is she loves colour

  • Mahima Satsangi
    Mahima Satsangi 2 months ago

    I like your eye look 😅🌸

  • Poke Bowl
    Poke Bowl 2 months ago

    I feel like the lips woulda looked better as a nude or pink liquid lipstick with a gloss on top. I woulda chosen KvD Lolita with and ABH nude gloss

  • Jüst NöthingToYoü
    Jüst NöthingToYoü 2 months ago

    Ar u left handed?

  • Hannah Childers
    Hannah Childers 2 months ago

    Jessica and Lynette are incredible

  • Mia maven
    Mia maven 2 months ago

    I hope safiya gave the girls a little something for their participation, like a lip balm or a bronzer and I hope the girl that loved the urban decay eyeshadow received one.

  • Katie Biedron
    Katie Biedron 2 months ago

    I have the vampira lipSTICK and it’s my favorite

  • Emily Mayaka
    Emily Mayaka 2 months ago


  • ash S
    ash S 2 months ago


  • Wizzle
    Wizzle 3 months ago

    derek is my spirit animal

  • Havanna Brown
    Havanna Brown 3 months ago

    you have bautifull eyes

  • Secret Runner Girl - The Hamilton Clan

    The lipstick is so dark [I’m still trying to get brave with color though] so it’s probably just me. You look amazing though!

  • Sadie & P.
    Sadie & P. 3 months ago

    She looks good! Love the lipstick and the foundation

  • Katie F
    Katie F 3 months ago

    Y’all film at Santa Anita mall in Arcadia don’t you?? I live so close by and I can recognize all the bird cage chairs and stuff in the background ahahaha

  • Meghan Simmons
    Meghan Simmons 3 months ago

    *Derrek remembers everything*

  • 10,000 subs without any videos? ꧂

    I know Im Weird but I would of matched the color of the eyeliner to the lips

  • ugly potato studios
    ugly potato studios 3 months ago

    how could u do this? i cant even ask strangers were the checkout is without ending up just walking away?!!!

  • Eva LIu
    Eva LIu 3 months ago

    that eyeliner is sooooo pretty!!!!!! I know damn well i wouldn't use it a lot, but i wanna get that

  • Sujatha Bay
    Sujatha Bay 3 months ago +1

    Lol you have so many pink the town blushes

  • Ruby Leigh
    Ruby Leigh 3 months ago

    This was the first video on this channel that I saw. It’s been about a year since I’ve subscribed and I’m just now watching this video again and it’s so crazy and nostalgic 😂

  • Tanya Purba
    Tanya Purba 3 months ago

    I just realize my sister has that highlighter kit😂

  • MâddøxGrêy
    MâddøxGrêy 3 months ago +1

    You look so beautiful without makeup. You have amazing clear skin!

  • Ella Powell
    Ella Powell 3 months ago

    The girl who chose the contour reminds me of Jane from Jane the Virgin for some reason. I think it’s the outfit?

  • Limabeanjellybean
    Limabeanjellybean 3 months ago

    Na na na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na na Na Na na Na Na Na Na

  • Audge Podge TM
    Audge Podge TM 3 months ago

    Can we take a moment to appreciate that the girls name is AMERICA? That’s the best name ever. I wish my name was America. Also, me moms name is Lanette.

  • Afton Ratzlaff
    Afton Ratzlaff 3 months ago

    You look so beautiful with AND without makeup! Love you Saf!
    PS I'm REALLY late so I wouldn't be surprised if Saf didn't respond.

  • sonia Quinn
    sonia Quinn 3 months ago

    You should let them buy makeup for them srlf

  • cecilia herrera
    cecilia herrera 3 months ago

    did no one else notice that the last guy was wearing a bt21 shirt? it had cooky on it and i was like oh shit wtf. also everyone please take a moment to appreciate safiya without make up?

  • A Rogers
    A Rogers 3 months ago

    Tbh I would SOOOOOOOO troll you.

    THE HUNT DOGS 3 months ago

    Y did no one troll her really good

  • Sad .Biscuit
    Sad .Biscuit 3 months ago

    MaKe AmErIcA gReAt AgAiN!
    America already looks adorable 😉

  • MIsheardNerd
    MIsheardNerd 3 months ago

    this video was amazing...i just have one question how do you get the people to come to you or get them

  • megan wood
    megan wood 3 months ago

    Love this look 😍

  • Anika Alam
    Anika Alam 3 months ago

    This is weird but I watch her videos a lot so I think she has three pink the town blushes

  • awkward error animations
    awkward error animations 3 months ago +1

    I would unintentionally troll you because I have absolutely no idea how to use makeup XD